Blog

Overbooking

Oct 03 2007

Airline overbooking. It's misjudged, misinterpreted, and mischaracterized. Most people don't understand it–if it were a person, it'd be an odd cross between Donald Trump and Truman Capote. You're not sure you get it, you don't think you like it, but it usually makes for an interesting story and is the butt of jokes by comedians on late-night talk shows. However, overbooking is actually easily explained and understood;  is the subject of a huge amount of statistical analysis; and is a bona-fide science in its own right!

Overbooking is the practice of accepting more reservations on a flight than there are seats. Most folks have two questions about overbooking: "why?" and "how?" The "why" is easy to explain–it's an airline's way of counteracting "no-shows," which are Customers who make confirmed reservations for flights and then, for whatever reason, fail to show up. Without overbooking, no-shows would cause almost all fully-booked flights to leave with empty seats. And an airline seat is a completely perishable commodity–when a seat on a flight departs the gate empty, it is lost and can't ever be used. Put another way, the potential for revenue lost due to no-shows could easily undermine Southwest's Low-Fare Leadership…and the art of overbooking helps prevents that.

That's the "why." The "how" is harder to explain, but it is way more interesting. The science surrounding overbooking combines the mathematics of probability and of detailed, historical analysis, mixes in a healthy measure of behavioralistic research, then uses all of that to predict what percentage of bookings for a given flight leg, on a given day, will fail to show up. The numbers of people that book but don't show have very definite trends that, absent a few "except for when this happens…" things thrown in just to keep things exciting, make predicting no-show rates a surprisingly exact and successful (if occasionally stressful) science.

Figuring out no-show rate exceptions--the "except for this" occurrences--can be one of the more challenging aspects of a Revenue Management Analyst's job. Some exceptions are easy to spot--holidays, for example, behave very differently than a normal week, but are usually identifiable and fairly predictable. Note that I said "fairly predictable"…some of the bigger holidays such as Christmas, New Year's, and Independence Day "float" to a different day of the week each year, and because of that they behave differently from year to year, making the job of predicting no-show rates and booking behavior, well, challenging at best!

Other little "GOTCHAS!" can only be explained through the investigative nature of an Analyst. Things like conventions, sports events, snowstorms, even the recent Customs computer outage at LAX that delayed thousands of arriving international Customers can really change no-show rates, sometimes far in advance of the flight, sometimes mere hours before departure. The only way an Analyst can identify seemingly inexplicable reasons behind odd booking and show rate behavior is through keeping close contacts with the no-show-rate trends, local Marketing Managers, fellow Southwest Airlines Employees at the Station…..and, frequently, local newspapers. Time for the Analysts to put on their "Investigative Reporter" hat to get to the bottom of the story!

While managing overbooking is just part of the job of our Warriors on the SWARM (Southwest Airlines Revenue Management) Team, it is a fascinating one that gets far too little attention–and even less appreciation. Their ability to maximize the number of filled seats while minimizing Customer inconvenience is incredible. Their effort is absolutely critical in giving the maximum number of Customers the Freedom to Fly. Keep us flying, SWARM--thank you!

Similar Posts

Comments

Bob Hurst makes a good point. If I've paid for a seat on a plane, but I don't show up, how is the airline losing money? If anything, they've saved money. The plane doesn't carry my weight, saving on fuel, doesn't feed me peanuts, doesn't give me soda. I don't compress the foam seats, irritate my seatmates, or hassle the attendants.

At a gym, they HOPE you'll never use your membership- it's free money. And a seat on a plane, paid for but unfilled, also seems like free money. Am I wrong?

Ã

I haven't figured out Southwest's pricing. It costs me $159 to fly from Baltimore to Florida and $49 to come back (same mileage each way) Yet it is $99 to California each way which is three times the distance and much more fuel. I have looked at pricing to Florida several different days and it is the same price each day to go to Ft. Lauderdale. Can someone explain this to me?

I haven't rummaged around on the blog to see if you have an entry about travel tips for Southwest customers, but this might be a good segue to such a blog. Maybe you could do a blog series on 10 ten travel tips. You could doe them from the prespective of each phase of your business. For example, you could to a list of top 10 travel tips from customers, one from baggage handlers, gate agents and so forth.

I always try to check online as soon as the 24 hour window opens up. Every time that I've done this, I have always been able to get in the A category. I don't fly much, but I usually try to fly on Southwest. In the last year, I've only failed to check in online once and get in the B section.

Great post, Bill, as usual!

Some people might think, "If the reservation is confirmed (as in paid for), why does Southwest care if the person doesn't show?"

Could you explain this?

Also, does Southwest handle overbooking and the resulting fallout differently than other airlines?

[...] Ted Mann wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptMost people donÃ