PLEASE LOGIN TO USE THE TRAY

Nuts About Southwest > Video Blog > Talking About the Changes

  Talking About the Changes

Talking About the Changes

Video: 

(Southwest Airlines CEO, Gary Kelly, has been reading your comments about our recently announced boarding and fare changes, and he wanted you to hear his thoughts directly.)

Comments

OK, Gary, I'm here, you can start now.

I have been a loyal, almost exclusive, Southwest customer since back in the 70's when you traveled between Dalls, Houston and San Antonio. When I was working full time I earned enough points to get the companion pass for several years. And I will say that I have enjoyed many Rapid Reward flights for me and my wife.
My concern now is that since I am now semiretired I only make one flight each month. That being from Tulsa, OK to one of the 7 West Coast states. With this in mind and after getting the mail about Tood Things Come To Those Who Wait, Like Not Waiting, I am dissapointed that I will be relagated to a B or C boarding pass since I will not achieve the 16 round trips in 12 months.
I just wanted to let you know that this program will cause me to shart shopping for an airline where I will not be looking at a center sear for long flights.
I would like your thoughts on this.
Thanks,
Larry Holt
1435 Buena Vista Circle
Springdale, AR
72762

After looking at the Business Select and the Business rates it looks like you have doubledl your fares. I am disspaointed. I think that you will find that this is not going to go over well with your regualr travelers.
Sorry,
Larry Holt

If, like me, you find that the embedded video is not showing up, the direct link to the video is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AUYpfJR4KEI

Whatever is supposed to be in the Gary-box did not come up on my #1 computer or my #2 computer. I think there is a problem with the site.

While I have no issue with the changes themselves, the implementation of these changes will be the key. Already, reports of gate Agents not enforcing the numerical order of the lineup has come up. This needs to get straightened out, and quickly. If someone has "paid for A", either by buying a BS fare or flying the required number of flights to be checked in at the 36 hour window, the lineup needs to be enforced. Otherwise, the A2 that came with that increased fare is worthless.

I'm Orlando based, a.k.a. massive family preboarding -- good luck if you just live here.

The new process has me looking at other airlines now and we will probably be droppig the Chase/Southwest Visa card. Once our Rapid Rewards are used we will probably go elsewhere now that Southwest is turning its back on a lot of customers, including me.

Dear Mr. Kelly,

I made the decision to switch to Southwest a few months ago; however, I'm already beginning to rethink that decision. Don't get my wrong, I absolutely love the changes your company has made with respect to boarding and otherwise. More importantly, I love the new attempts to appeal specifically to business passengers.

But with this new business-passenger approach, why would you discontinue your Chicago to New York flights??? I recently attempted to book a flight from MDW to LGA in February, only to shockingly learn that those flights are being discontinued in January.

Mr. Kelly, I respect your efforts to attract the business class. But how do you intend to keep that business if you don't offer one of the most popular routes around?

Please feel free to contact me at my e-mail address above. Having truly enjoyed my last few months since switching to Southwest, I'd love to hear why I should stay in light of my MDW-LGA concerns.

Thanks,

Scott Kramer

I am thrilled with the new boarding process. It is very frustrating to have booked early have an A3 ticket and watch the "pre-boards" Families with children OVER 5yrs walk right on and the Agents say nothing. Reserved spots in the line at the gate and my favorite, the FAKE handicap. How dare you! You should be so lucky NOT to have a disability but you stand there like nobody notices. If a wheelchair is required to get a passenger to a plane, doesn't it make sense that this passenger would require a chair to exit the plane? It's funny, people almost receive miracle "cures" during flight and require no assistance at their destination and will knock you over to get off the plane and get theur luggage FIRST. HOORAY for you! The new boarding process won't fix this, but this does need to be addressed. Thank you Southwest for your continued great service!!

Gary,
Thank you for asking for opnions. My name is John Zimmerman. I am about to go to Central Missouri State university. I am going to be a pilot. I attended your open house on june,10,2006. My passion for Southwest is strong, and hope to become a member of the Southwest Family and Culture. I NEVER flown on any commerical airplane except Soutwest. I loved the old new boarding pass system. First to checkin first to board no camping out in lines. I fly 9 roundtrips a year. Its puts a distaste in mouth now than I am or at least feel the I am being pushed away. I give you the best advetising there is word of mouth. I still think you are the best airline. I have been so loyal there was one time I changed flights and because of the flight change there was a sale that would have saved oh about 20 dollars, because you know you book at the current avaible price What did I do? I selected the fun fare instead of the internet one way and paid 8 dollars more.I did that because I felt bad about changing my flight on you 23 days in advance. When I am waiting at the gate and people are complaing(which did not happen often I defended you (southwest) and the employees. I feel sad that this is my reward for my loyality. I understand that you need to make more due to fuel. I for one would support a general fare increase instead. Ok 15-30 dollars higher a ticket fine . Maybe you could reward the people who fly 32 one way say a discount not offered to the general public? But again I love the concept of A1 A2 A3,etc. I just dont like the new business select or a-list. Oh yea by the way the new fare system is great. However I can see why people think fares are increasing. Problem with that is they dont see the red unavalable on the website. I checked prices on the 3 flights that I have booked now, and belive it or not they were the same if not lower.

Thanks for your time gary,

John Zimmerman

P.S I am hoping to have a good experiance with this system on December 17

My husband and I have flown Southwest for years because the airline flys where we want to go. Half the fun of flying SW was standing in line and trying to get the seats that you desired. I guess the new boarding system will work OK; we are willing to give it a chance. It was my understanding that families with children 4 and under would board between the A group and the B group, has this concept changed? Also, what if there are 8 or 10 people in the family and only one child 4 or under, how is that handled? We flew out of Reno the other night with only about 12 or so passengers, so that was not a good indication of how the new system works. Although there was a couple who decided that because they were #15 & #16 they should be at the head of the line and not get behind the other people who had already lined up when the flight was called. Oh well..

Scott Kramer,
The discontinuation of MDW to LGA was done by southwests code share partner ATA. Southwest has no control over what routes ATA wishes to discontinue.
https://www.ata.com/travel/custrelations/customerInquiry.do
I have a link for you that will allow you to contact ATA and let them know of your concern.

Joe

Living in Europe I don't get the opportunity to fly Southwest that often. However I do fly SWA when on business in the US. I like SWA efficiency (which is reflected in the fares) and simplicity. The plane is, for me, a means to get from A to B. Getting to B faster is worth some money; reliability and punctuality is worth some too.
When I use frequent flyer perks, it is to avoid queues. I don't mind being at the end of the A's with online check-in (no queue there!) I don't care for "business class treatment" on short flights, will not pay for "priority boarding" (move the waiting from the gate area to your plane seat). I haven't seen the "number boarding" system, but it seems an improvement.
Don't lower SWA to the standards of "major airlines".

P.S. Did not feel like installing Flash, just for a video.

Mr Kelly,

I do like the new boarding process so if I get an A pass, I won't have to show up to the airport 2 hours before my flight to get a good seat.
I agree with what a lot of other people have said about the new pricing changes and do not like it.
One more comment...Southwest doesn't seem to expand into other cities like some other airlines have, it would be nice to see Southwest move into other cities so I'm not forced to fly more expensive airlines. I know SWA uses market data to decide which airports to move into but why can't you start a thread in the blog asking what readers and your current customers want?
I'm sure you could move into other markets just by flying into key cities such as Las Vegas, Baltimore, Orlando, and Chicago then expand if needed.

Forget about the boarding procedure, I got to see Paula's bright shining face this morning. What a great way to start the day :)

Aw...thanks, Brody! Now I'll be smiling all day!

I thought the point of the new boarding was to eliminate the cattle call line???? This in no way is happening in the way it is presented in your website "tutorial". "Sit and relax"?????

No, now we are forced to line up numerically like 1st graders in a lunch line.

This is not a step forward, and for as much as I fly your airlines for work, it is a great disappointment. I was so looking forward to an improvement!!

Dear Mr. Kelly,
I have flown Southwest almost exclusively in the last 5-7 years and I think the new changes in your boarding will also make me look to other airlines for my flights. Yes, the fun was in trying to get the #1 or #2 seats, but since I will probably now be in the "B" line, since we only fly 4 times a year, Southwest won't be my first choice.
We knew it was too good to be true! And now it's gone.
See ya,
Kathy

Sorry but that speech seemed more political than anything to me..
It didn't really hit on any of the real key points of concern..
What seems to be hitting me in the heart more than anything is a post by someone named Dennis regarding boarding with his children..
The SW response to his concern regarding being given boarding numbers that put as many as 50 people between him and his children truly doesn't seem adequate..
Because he brought his children he is no longer an A lister??
Basically you are saying either he moves back in the line because he is an A lister or he is to leave his children alone and save them a seat??
So he loses his privileges for flying so many times with SWA or he leaves the kids behind and hopes that they will be ok unattended..??
So the perks of becoming a frequent flier are good unless of course you have children and you are calling this "catering to families"???
Maybe its me but the common sense on this one truly eludes me...
So say my husband and I make the A list as we would have many times in the past and we want to take our grandchildren on a trip, that means that when we want to fly with them we are no longer A list customers...
This tells me that actually unless of course your kids don't go to school most of the year and they travel with you most of the time, these programs are catering more to adults than to families whether that be children or grandchildren...
So the perks of this program are what???
I realize that you have worked hard on this program but why can't you see that it could have areas that are flawed and maybe need some tweeking a bit...
I could fly 200 times a year but if I bring my grandchildren on only two trips a year the other 198 trips don't count while traveling with my grandchildren because on those two I have brought them with me and they are not on the A list..
I'm not sure exactly how this reward program could possibly be looked at as family friendly in the real world the adults, moms, dads, grandparents are more likely to be part of the A list which leaves A list folks with children that are not A list to always be behind the remaining A list folks or leaving their children unattended while they save seats..
In other words unless entire families are ALL A list, children included, families have to make the choice of staying together in the airport or taking advantage of a program that is basically set up for adults that travel much more than children do..
Maybe its worked for some that were lucky enough to get numbers close enough together but I see a potential problem with adults getting numbers as many as 50 between them and the kids...Which has obviously happened as per the post by Dennis..
Your catering to the most frequent fliers and generally that isn't the children, so get your A list boarding pass, just don't bring the kids with you or you ALL lose...

Kathy,

You're right. That was the good ole days when it was a game to try to get #1. Even when they came out with numbered boarding, I thought that was cool. Why they teased us with announcing that and coming out with the business select and A-listers just a short time later I'll never understand. Like Gary said, no one likes changes. Like he said, times are changing and he went after those business flyers and is trying to get them on board-no pun intended. I always got to the gate at least 1 1/2 hours early to get that coveted exit aisle seat. Sadly, those days are done unless I opt to purchase the highest price ticket. I would have been an A -lister 12 months ago, but to due to the slowing economy I'm not flying enough to qualify. Kudos to Gary for making the video and giving us customers a forum to respond. My next flight is the week after Thanksgiving and I'll be anxious to see how things are working by then. And Paula, I think you should lead off a video at least once a month. Like Brody said, its a nice way to start our day.

I fly 50 round trips a year and have flown on 2 segments since the new boarding program. I possessed an A16 and A17 respectivly. In both cases, when the gate agent said "Welcome aboard A1-A30." passengers who were previously sitting in front of the gate cut in front of us with A16 on. I looked at the boarding pass # of the person who cut in front of me in the first leg, A27. When the same thing happened on the second leg, I asked the person in front of me and was told to "xxxx off." If the gate agent does not enforce the rules, the new boarding procedures are doomed to fail.

Why not board in groups of five. I can't see this slowing down the boarding procedure.

I just returned from my first experience with the new boarding process. I believe it went smoothly and stopped much of the fighting for position in line. However, I noticed that the numerical order was not enforced, which is somewhat hippo critical of the process. I was in the front of B line watching the A group board and a gentleman who was in group A was with a Lady friend who was a B. He simply stated 'She's with me' and the southwest employee, without any regard, let her board with him. They were both adults with out any special needs, she should have waited in B line with everyone else. Southwest definitely needs time to iron out the many kinks to this boarding process and train their employee how to enforce this policy. I still support SWA!!!

Cindy wrote: "I realize that you have worked hard on this program but why canÃ

Can someone estimate roughly how many Southwest customers have flown 32 one-way flights over the last 365 calendar days. Since Southwest has the ability to fly roughly 448,000 (3300 flights times 136 (avg seat capacity)) customers per day. I'm trying to figure the average number of A-listers to be expected.

I have expressed my ideas in a posting on the original presentation of the idea. Quick synopsis: people need to take a deep breath, relax, let things become established and evaluate after having experienced it - not based on emotional arguments about not feeling equal because they can't get A1 anymore. I DID agree with some posters that for purely PR reasons, families should just pre-board, with LIMITS. But other than that, I agree with SWA about the changes it needs to make in order to keep fares nice and pretty for the rest of us.

Yet people continue to say they don't like it either before they have tried it or purely because they didn't feel equal having to line up further back. Before coming to medical school, I was a Middle School teacher - and boy oh boy, it's a good thing Mr. Kelly doesn't run SWA the way I ran my classroom in Baltimore City. He has shown patience, kindness, an openness to listen, etc. In my class, whiners were told to grow up - end of story.

Furthermore, I did some math: (Mr. Kelly or Ms. Berg, please correct errors I probably made) But there are about 137 seats on an airplane, 6 seats across. That means about 23 rows in an airplane - each of those rows has 2 window seats, 2 aisle seats, and 2 middle seats. That means there are 4 seats per row that somebody would prefer and only 2 that somebody would rather avoid (middle seat). 4x23=92. Assuming an absolutely full airplane, that still means all the A group (even A60) gets a desirable seat and the majority of B group gets a desirable seat. And since SWA is only selling 15 Select fares, that leaves a whole lotta nice seats for everyone else. If somebody wants to pay that much more to park themselves on the same "EQUAL" leather seat as SWA made available to me for way less than the competitor, I'm all for it!

Let's not confuse SWA's mission - to me, their mission and goal is to provide the Freedom to Fly to everyone. Unlike a previous blogger who advocates across the board increases in fares in order to maintain the proverbial "equality" everyone keeps talking about, I WOULD rather SWA give some perks to people who are paying way more if it means I get to keep the freedom to see my family, go on a vacation, and explore this great country of ours.

People, there are way more important things we could be worrying ourselves over rather than A3 vs. B47. Grow up.

About a month ago I received a card from Southwest congratulating me on being a Rapid Rewards member for 20 years. That should establish that I am not new to Southwest Airlines. Over the past 15 years I built my company by sticking to one principal regarding travel. We fly only Southwest Airlines. Regardless of where we are going, we fly SWA then drive the rest of the way. The recent changes to the SWA fare structure has left me scratching my head. It seems to me you've lost your touch. For 15 years I never looked at other airlines because I knew SWA had the best fares and the most flexible policies. I'm scared of the changes I see in place, and even more concerned about what they foretell. Small businesses that build a nationwide base of customers depend on Southwest to make travel affordable. I just finished looking for flights on the new website and was appaled by what I found. The fares seemed to have skyrocketed. I agree with what a lot of other people have said about the new pricing changes and do not like it. Is there any room for you to rethink this? I hope so.

here is a picture of what Artie is talking about
http://www.seatguru.com/airlines/Southwest_Airlines/Southwest_Airlines_B...

Joe

My first experience with the new boarding pass policy went well. I checked in on-line a little less than 24 hours before my flight and recieved A 27, which allowed me to board in the first group (A1 - A30).

My second experience was less rewarding. I made sure to check in on-line at exactly 24 hours prior to the flight, to the minute. This time I recieved A 46. That surprised me since I sat at my computer and made sure that I checked in within the first minute possible. I was a bit shocked to think that 45 people were able to check in before me.

Now I am begining to wonder how soon it will be before I will not be able to even get an A pass on-line. Flying in anything other than an aisle seat is very uncomfortable for me. I did not mind showing up early for flights to get in line in order to get an aisle seat. It will not always be feasible to check in at the exact minute 24 hours in advance. If checking in exactly on-time gets spot number 46, I dread to think what position I would get if I checked in only 23 hours in advance.

I would prefer to see either a return to the old way of doing things, or moving all the way to being able to preview and select seats on-line.

Thanks,
Jerry

I think this might be too much change in such a small amount of time. For me waiting in line for a good seat was like a southwest airlines tradition. I think the Southwest Airlines customers liked the airline just the way it was and you are trying waay to hard to get buisness travelers. It almost seams like Southwest is leaning towards legacy style with their changes. But the changes dont really effect my buissness with the airline.

Many interesting comments presented here. Especially love Elaine's observations regarding the "healing power" of a SW 737. I too have seen far too many "injured" pax preboard in "alleged pain" only to exit 1-2 hrs later "fully healed" etc. Add to that the "teaching powers" of a SW 737. Time and again I've seen pax feign "no English" spoken to wangle a preboard (why using sign language qualifies you for preboard I do not know). Anyhow, time and again, these same folks exit the flight speaking fluent English. The power of these 737's boarders on the mystical.

Also agree with comments by Mike and Drew regarding gate agents calling a1-a30 instead of in 5 or 10 unit increments. These agents need to regain control of their gates before the holidays. Otherwise madness will rule.

I agree with the ealerier flyer who left this message," While I have no issue with the changes themselves, the implementation of these changes will be the key." I've just signed in on-line to print my boarding pass 24 hours in advance and have received the following message. You are not checked in for your flight. Proceed to gate for boarding pass. I called the 800 customer service and they said their were no more tickets available to print from the on-line check-in. She assured me that I was A-listed, but that I couldn't check in and print my boarding pass. I flew this morning and I was A-listed and when I checked in I at the gate I was awarded B-55 which was hardly an A-listing. What gives with this new system? Now I have no boarding pass and I'm at the murcy of a person at the airport. I check-in on-line so I don't have to waste time interfacing with a human who doesn't have my interests at heart. The computer system is unbiased and that was the success of the program. The implementation process needs to be fixed so a frequent A-flier can again check-in on-line before they go to the airport. In the old system at least you received your boarding pass and knew where you stood A, B or C before arriving at the airport. Please fix it.

I hate the new method of boarding. Anybody that didn't like the old method just didn't understand it. I grew up on Southwest having only flown on a handful of other airlines. If you are going to assign boarding order I don't understand why you wouldn't assign seating. Don't get me wrong, I don't like assigned seats either but I don't understand the one without the other. I really hope this gets changed back and the people who came up with this bright idea find themselves working at Delta or somewhere. What a crock!!!!!!!!!

Just flew Southwest today and experienced the new boarding process for the first time. It worked great. Travelers that are concerned should give it more of a chance. Don't make snap judgements. Don't be afraid of change. It really hasn't changed that much. Relax!!! You still get an A, B, or C and you still get to choose your seat. What is the big deal? One thing remains consistent: great ontime service.

Thank you Southwest. You are by far the best around.

I'm not sure that Gary and the various SW people are on firm ground in saying that we customers are rigidly against change. We are angry that we bought tickets under one system and now have to use them under another, especially over Thanksgiving and Christmas. However, at this point we are tied to our November-December tickets, like it or not, having already paid for them. Going forward (Jan through May), we shifted within the first two days after the SW announcement to schedule future flights on other airlines where things are more predictable at this time. We can't wait to try a lot of SW flights before making future reservations --- we have to go ahead based on information that we have now, which is that there is variation and confusion in current SW operations. Whatever Gary thinks, we are not a collection of concrete blocks out here. In a year or so, when this round of changes has settled down, we will reconsider SW as if it was a new airline. The old LUV, which had great spirit and great performance, now is gone. We are not wasting any time on nostalgia.

As a dedicated and frequent flyer on Southwest, when I first heard that SW was going to board people basaed on the letter and number on their boarding pass, I though that was fair and convenient. But when I read about how SW was going to sell "A" pass seat to those capable and willing to pay for them, I had a very negative reaction. Southwest was built on the Joe Six Packs and Grannies of the world wating to fly for personal reasons. Now, it appears that you are catering to the business flyer. I fly to assist my non-profit clients in the management of their associations. It is they not me that pays for the fare and I am duty bound to get the lowest and best fare.

(finishing previous comments) I agree with many of your customers that the pre-boarding procedures and rights were grossly abused and needed change. For many years when flying North and South it was exclusively on U.S. Air and East and West it was on Continental. Now its Southwest even when it is not totally convenient. Today, I try your new system for the first time in a flight from Tampa to Birmingham and back. As we use to say in the news business, "Film at 11" . P.S. Thanks for the LUV Voucher for that infamous flight from Tampa to Las Vegas and the emergency stop in New Orleans because of the powder spill in the bathroom.

I work for southwest in Tampa, Fl and I can say after being in the gate area for the past week I have noticed a very positive change when we are boarding. I understand families being nervous about sitting together , I have a 7 yo son and I share that same dilema. We communicate with our flight attendants and make sure there are going to be seats together when "family boarding" begins. Another positive note is when we announce a gate change, In the past you would have hundreds lined up in the gate area and when we announced that the gate has changed you could witness complete chaos with people actually trying to run over each other because they didn't want to lose thier place in line. In the past when a flight had a delay our passengers were standing in line for the 40 minutes prior to boarding and then they sat in line for the remainder of the delay. This new boarding process eliminates that. I just watch our passengers and now they are sitting in chairs instead of laying on the floor or standing for an extra 40-50 minutes. Also families have the same chance of obtaining an "A" boarding pass as any other passenger. I have heard a lot of the same concerns from other passengers at the gate and I understand that we may lose some costumers because of these changes but I don't think you will find a more friendly set of employees than ours and that makes all the difference at the end of the trip.

I just HAD to put my 2 cents worth into this blog.
When I'm working, I thank our customers EVERY DAY! Job security one more day. Thank you for 'shopping' Southwest Airlines. With every change that has come along, I tell our customers to please be patient with us as WE are learning it as well.
Change is inevitable; remember plastic boarding passes, string bag tags, dial telephones, 8-track tapes, our 13-year old son who now sounds like a 21-year old on the phone........the list AND life goes on.
The amazing thing about Southwest Airlines is that they DO listen to their customers, unlike other airlines, so if more changes need to be made, it will happen.
Isn't it wonderful, too, that we have the freedom to move about the country (on Southwest Airlines, of course) as well as express our opinions about anything and everything?!!! Thank you~!!!
OK, that was my dime's worth, can someone please make change?

As a flight attendant for Southwest, I have noticed that since the new boarding procedures have have started, it seems like the plane is being boarded a little faster. I am pleased the family boarding is after the 'A' group as well.

In talking with passengers, most of them just don't understand why we've changed our procedure... after explaining what I've learned about the new boarding, the passengers seem to understand a little better. I think change is change and some people don't like change. Like Gary said in the video- we can't be everything to everyone... but I think this will keep our loyal customers loyal by not assigning a seat... but then again, this will keep away some passengers who like to have an assigned seat.

Just a note: Most of the passengers who I've talked to actually prefer the new procedure.

Just weeks ago I was telling my family how happy I was about the new boarding process--and looking forward to avoiding the ugly scenes I so often found in the lines as passengers would make up and enforce their own rules about "where the A line was" and who was entitled to stand/sit where. I was touting how wonderful the new solution was. I was singing Southwest's praises to anyone who would listen, as I have for years.

Then you announced this new elitist Business preference program and I am now heartsick. Southwest was the one egalitarian airline where all passengers were equal and no one a second-class citizen. All you had to do to be in the "A" group was PLAN. Now, you're essentially allowing people to buy their way into the "A" group--instantly relegating those of us who have to choose the cheapest fares to the back of the line. For many of us, it's not about being thrifty; it's about whether we can afford to fly at all.

I'm a Rapid Rewards member and have flown Southwest exclusively for the last four years, as much for the egalitarian culture as for the low fares. Now, there's no reason not to look at airlines that allow me to choose my own seat--or have more amenities (Jet Blue). I'm so sad about this. Is there NO place in American life where money doesn't buy privelege???

I hope you realize that this decision will be costing you your reputation as well as longtime customers.

Folks this is real simple. America (thanks to our Gov't) is becoming another post WWII Germany with the rights and liberty's being stripped away little by little and day by day. We whom believe in what our forefathers started, should be outraged and furious at the mockery of our veterans who fought for rights that now are tossed away by political idiots. Example: Immigration rules. WAKE UP AMERICA !!! Look back 100 yrs to what our then president said about the english language here in America. Southwest just plain SHAME ON YOU. Southwest remember we still have the freedom to put you out of business by using other airlines. Signed Tired & Disgusted with Americas double standard of the rich over the middle & poor class

Would it have been too much to ask Gary to shoot the video dressed up as Edna Turnblad? :D

Good job Southwest!

I have been a customer for years and know that things change according to the times! You all should realize this as well and for that I commend SWA! My cardinal rule is you get what you pay for, meaning, its not the era of meals anymore or inflight entertainment. Customers want low fares and with low fares you got to remember you get what you pay for! I have no complaints about my ticket being as low as possible! Here is a thought EAT before flying or buy something at the airport for your flight! Also bring something to do A BOOK! DVD PLAYER! I know hard to understand right???? Sorry to preach but once again I LOVE SWA!

Loyal Customer,

Ian Dahl

Lady in 3 piece suit to companion on LUV flight: "UA still doesn't get it. I want to get to my destination." A UA type gate circus is not an attraction for this business traveler. Don't emulate the most hated airline flying today.

Hi SWA~
I certainly hope you DO read these comments. I am really upset about the changes and have already booked my next West coast flight on another Houston based airline. Why?

1. NO Enforcement of the Boarding pass numbers, just flew 6 flights in the last week. Mob rush to the gate attendent.
2. Rarely I fly with my toddlers and when I do, I want to get them situated before the mad rush of rude "Carry-on loaders"
3. It's a challenge to fly SWA at times, but I did so just because of my Rapid reward points. Now, I think I might not have the 16 RT's a year, therefore be relagated to B or C status, and the dreaded middle seat when flying alone.
4. Disappointment that no one enforces the HUGE carryons people bring on. I always check my bag because I dont want to hassle with it, but most folks don't.
5. Disappointment with the way SWA has changed for the worse.

Thank you for asking.
We don't like this at all!

Longtime Loyal Customer now diappointed and taking my $$$ elsewhere.

Artie - your math looks good to me! Excellent point.

I echo other comments that I was pleased to hear of the initial boarding changes. Adding the numbers seemed like it would eliminate the need to go sit on the floor an hour and a half before a flight. A welcome change. And I was happy to hear of the change in family pre-boarding. Families can plan ahead just like the rest of us and print our boarding passes 24 hours in advance and get in the A group. Everyone seems to take a long time getting into their seats and stands out in the aisle, so I don't see much difference for families (if we all tried to either move to the back or step into the row and let people pass, that would sure help things though!).

But the change in offering priority boarding to those who paid more does not sit well with me at all. One of the things I despise about the other airlines is the "class system" they have. First class, Priority Class, etc. Its ridiculous. Southwest has always been different and it feels great to feel equal to everyone on the flight. Now that all changes. I don't have an equal chance to get the good seats (I'm a fearful flier and seating is a big deal for me) or the opportunity to get on ahead of the crowd unless I pay more. I work for a non-profit so when I fly on business its not ethical to pay more for this privelege. And I work for a non-profit, so I don't make enough to be able to just pay for priveleges I want when I'm on personal trips. I'm not willing to say I'm done with Southwest, but I will definitely explore more options than I have in the past as they become more like all the other airlines.

I'm very disappointed to see Southwest, the airline that really seemed to be the people's airline, suddenly implementing a class system. A very sad day...

Dear Gary:
Twice now I have tried to use my Rapid Reward free tickets and twice I am told that those seats are sold out. I work for a non-profit and can't afford to take much time away from work, but I do need to visit my 91 year old mother in Seattle. This policy new policy is the pits.
In the past I have been able to use them if there were any seats available and employees were extreamly helpful. Now I am being told that "those seats" are not available. I can't extend my days off.
My alturnative is find another airline. Is that what you really want? I have been a faithful Southwest Airline supporter and user for years. This policy is not user friendly and will cost you support.
Please reconsider and allow our free tickets to be of real value.
Gale Thomssen, Tucson AZ

To The CEO of Southwest'
I would Like to Commend your employee and employes on the handling of the situation with the UNDERDRESSED PASSENGER! that has been in the news. I believe you and your emp's handled that PERFECTLY and if that is your position about your airlines and your position with regards to morale and integrity you have my support and the majority support of numerous traditional americans! Thank You for trying to provide a flight service that I can bring my family and children on without worrying if the main display will be someone dressed like a porno star getting ready for the next scene! I genuinely wish hope and pray for the best for You and Your employees for all that you provide for your customers!

Kelly Gibson
KellyKellyGibson@aol.com

I've actually been fine with the changes Southwest has implemented over the past few months. I don't pay the higher business travel fares and I'm just a "regular joe." But I enjoy not having to cram into line with all the other A, B, or C travelers (I never do anyway, just sit back and wait until the end of the line is next).

I know these changes were brought about after much deliberation, and I appreciate that the company's making a marked effort to meet its customer's needs (and demands). Keep up the great work -- I know I'm just one of many that will continue to use your services!

Regarding Kyla Ebbert, the Hooters girl who apparently has ZERO modesty:

The more I hear of this, the more proud I am of the employee who had her adjust what little clothing she was wearing before reentering the plane. Finally, SOMEONE who has the moxie to stand up and say, "That's inappropriate!"

There was once a time in the not-so-distant past when females who dressed this way in public were considered hookers. Unfortunately, our society has loosed its morals to the point that when someone approaches another and says something like, "Please properly cover yourself . . . your attire is offensive," the inappropriately dressed person makes a big STINK of it and gets on national news and the person who makes the comment is scorned. WOW! Shouldn't it be the other way around?

THANK YOU for taking a stand!!! The public has got to know that there ARE those who disapprove of people who lack decency flaunting it in the faces of people who dare cover themselves!

The thing that gets me is Playboy hired this girl to have nude pictures taken. The mother was talked into approving her daughter to pose nude and the father finally caved in. Oh, yeah, I'd like my daughter's naked body on every magazine stand across America!

She aspires to be an attorney . . . FOXNews.com states:

Ebbert worked at a Hooters in San Diego but said wants to become an attorney, and doesn't think posing nude should get in the way of her professional aspirations. "This was beautiful and classy. I don't see why it would affect a professional position," she said. "I'd do it again in a heartbeat."

Wouldn't you love to be there to say, "I told you so"? I believe it WILL and SHOULD interfere with her becoming an attorney!

KUDOS TO SOUTHWEST!!!!!!!!!

Ok even after reading the article in BusinessWeek.com about how change may be bad for SWA, and reading the 70% negative comments on here I am still undecided. I happen to fall into that "Road Warrior" group where I might fly 4-5 flights a week. I was notified that I would be given "A" Group boarding from here out but that was not I was told when I called SWA. I haven't actually flown on SWA however since the changes but am anxious to see if its good or bad. I am also curious to see how this affects security lines, as now people are no longer flocking there early to hold their place in the A,B,or C line. I fly to L.A. at least 2 times a month, and it scares me to know that flying from BNA to LAX (4 hour flight) that I might have to be in the middle so often. Only time will tell if this is good or bad, I will say PRICES GOT HIGHER!!! That's all that matters, let people pay the high fairs for the good seats if that means keeping other fares cheaper. Let them have that $30 cocktail if it means keeping my personal travel cheaper. I will say, SWA is the best airline, they are so highly involved in the communities, businesses, and their customer's everyday lives. They truly are a company that cares and reaches out with its philanthropy. When is the last time someone saw a story or article on United Airlines doing anything but bickering, scratching, and clawing its way in and out of bankruptcy.

As for the post by TERRY, don't compare this change to a post WWII Germany or our American Liberties being stripped away. You sir are being a little dramatic there and we have the liberty to fly or choose. Be thankful we have an airlline that lets us afford to travel to see our friends, families, or affords us efficienes in our pursuit of capitalistic endeavors. Thanks to SWA, our famililes are closer, we can see our friends more often, and LUV is in the air.

IF YOU WANT LOYALTY FROM YOUR CUSTOMERS YOU HAVE TO BE LOYAL TO YOUR CUSTOMER BASE.

I fly Southwest a great deal. 80% or so of the flights out of my home airport of Nashville are SWA. I have always enjoyed the airline and appreciated the smiling faces and the ability to make a profit on your own two feet.

I was pleased with the news of the Letter / Number system to eliminate the "cattle call". This seems like a good evolutionary step.

However, I'm deeply troubled by the preferential seating for the "Business Select" fares, and frequent fliers. When its all said and done, this essentially means B&C for everyone else. In talking with many of my fellow fliers, I think the switch to the Letter/Number system would have been enough to incent a lot more business travelers who are often paying at or near full fare.

I know you don't really care because its an issue of who paid more, but most of your guaranteed "A's" will be flying single anyway, while families, couples, and others will be spread all over the plane because they all have C tickets.

Typical boarding of your competitors:
"We'll now take our Super Duper A+ World Class Platinum Passengers"...."We'll now take our Preferred Gold Glass Passengers"..."We'll now take our Silver Select Elite Passengers"....."Ok - the rest of you third-rate wastes-of-our-time get on, sit down, shut up and don't ask for anything".

If you get to close to the same thing, I'll fly with them. At least their planes are only half-full and you have plenty of room. Besides, maybe it will save me some taxes to bail them out.

I guess people just don't get it. There are SIXTY A boarding passes. Unless a combination of SIXTY Rapid Reward or Business Select passengers happen to walk up if you print your boarding pass out 24 hours you will get an A boarding pass.

Besides, I'd rather have time before the flight to go get food, coffee, or a newspaper.

You can always head over to American Airlines where they have assigned seats. Oh, yeah, they love to change equipment. There goes your window emergency exit row seat! I've flown them a lot of times. They board late, depart late, and arrive late. SWA? Usually on time.

Chill, peeps.

Thanks to the SWA CSA's and flight attendants for their experiences with the new system. Its good to hear their comments, though I would expect most to be good. I am sure management is concerned with the horror stories of some CSA's not implementing the system correctly. I've made many comments about the new system, but now is the time to give it a chance. Again, thank you SWA personnel for your comments and experiences. I'm sure on Monday evening, Nov 26, we will hear a big sign of relief from SWA personnel that the Thanksgiving travel is complete.

I am using a Rapid Rewards Award for a flight tomorrow and my wife is flying on my companion pass. I just printed our boarding passes and got A21 and A23 for the first segment and A17 and A19 for the second. So far, so good. The bad news is that when I was looking at changing the flight several days ago I noticed that it is no longer possible to get the last seat on the plane with a Rapid Rewards Award. The number of seats available for Rapid Rewards Award use now seems to be very limited and in order to get the same flexibility that I had under the old system I will have to convert two Standard Awards into a Freedom Award. In effect, Southwest has doubled the number of segments for a "useful" award from 16 to 32. I fly Southwest exclusively because of the Rapid Reward program and think that this was a very disappointing improvement. I can understand all the other changes but this one is hitting me directly in the pocket book and I am surprised that it hasn't been discussed on this blog.

The new Boarding procedure SUCKS....really!!! As a business traveller I have taken my last trip on SouthWorst Airlines. Honestly, If we're going to buy a seat, then sell me a seat...one where I can put my briefcase near me, not 5 rows away because all the A boarded or pre-boarded families take up entire overhead bins, but skip seats, cuz noone wants the middle seat. It's just reached the point of stupidity. In an ideal world a Business traveller likes to fly first class...get on the plane LAST and de-plane First...this whole program is a joke...gate personnel not changing the A: sign to the B: sign, causing confusion, pushy customers just being allowed to do what they want...it really has deteriorated to the point where you now simply feel like a cow....

Maybe you guys could save some more money by extending a trough through the middle aisle and just dump a big bag of peanuts in at the front and whatever's left for the dumb cows in the back is the way it is.

It'd save money on peanut wrapper packaging, labor to clean up etc....

I'm done with SouthWorst...today I have removed it from our company travel options for employees...and all I can do is my part to see it's foolish behaviors fall prey to the lack of cohesive management willing to step up and recognize yet another BAD IDEA....

Steve.

I'm certainly for any changes that remove the need to sit in line to reserve one's spot. However, I can't adequately express my dismay regarding preferential seating for higher-paying customers. I became intensely loyal to Southwest after taking my first flight with them. Now, I need to reconsider. Please, no elitism for seating!

Yes, I have enjoyed the good times while they lasted. The competition that began 24 hours prior to a flight to get an A Group was a great equalizer. The business traveller who must fly as cheaply as possible, has a chance of a good seat, no luxuries, but fun nontheless.

So, tell me - once you have enough people buying business fares to bump loyal customers out of the 'A' Group and into a position where other airlines can now compete on price for guaranteed seats, will Southwest stop growing so quickly? I flew more business related miles on Southwest this year than on any other airline, thanks for the free flights, drink coupons, and extra peanuts - next year may be different - time will tell. Oh and the promise of better boarding as a result of flying 16 round trips - well, there are only so many A Seats to go around!

I heard your video response. I work for a big company too. Your response was typical PR BS. The founder of a company would never say that "replacement CEO" crap.

SWA now is just like all the other airlines so I guess there's no need for me to prefer SWA over any other airline when I'm planning my trips.

Once the founder leaves as the leader of his company and is replaced by a "business school" grad that is bottom line oriented and only lives to meet "Wall Street's" expectations, that company becomes just another cookie cutter business school case study. Too bad for SWA.

Southwest just lost my business. I fly SNAPHX twice a month and have always flown SWA. But their new fares are ridiculous. Booking this trip for late Jan 2008, SWA wants over $200!! USAir comes in at $118. Bye bye, SWA. I also checked the same trip for late Feb. Same ridiculously high fare. Ta-ta, SWA.

And forget about wooing business customers. No in-seat power, no entertainment, no assigned seating.

The glory days are over for SWA. I'm sorry to see that happen, but economics are economics.

I have been a loyal Southwest fan for about 10 years now and i loved that i would get the ticketless awards from flying, booking online and using my credit card. Well, the past few flights i wanted to fly there were no seats available for ticketless awards. I used to never have this issue, which was a HUGE reason i loved flying southwest. I could fly when and where i wanted. Now it doesn't seem to matter I can only fly when and where you want me to or i pay like everyone else. If i have to pay normal fares I am going to do it where i get an assigned seat. In fact the past 4 times i have flown my ticketless awards wouldn't work so i flew other airlines, which it looks like is going to have to happen again. So much for enjoying the great customer service and appreciation that southwest once provided. I guess it's time to use my other flight miles from other airlines and credit cards.

I think it was shifty to tell folks that the fare increase was only 10 to 30 dollars more when that only involved full fares which most ordinary folks do not take.

Those ordinary folks made your airline great and now you have made the big expense acconut guys able to beat out the regulars for seat selection. I can't understand why anyone would pay more for the same size seats anyway. Most of the big spenders will go first class on another carrier anyway.

I like the "cattle call "line because it rewarded the early birds and folks who were not to lazy to get off their duffs. It was a level playing field.

You will not admit your mistake because it will reflect on you in the boardroom ,but I bet your bottom line will show the failure in a few months.
I can afford to go first class on anyother airline but I chose Southwest because of the simple way you did things, but now you choose to reward those who have the big expense accounts and put the guys who made you great in the "back of the bus". A stupid error and you will see that in the coming months.

I wonder what Herb thinks? Surely this wasn't his idea. The stockholders need to start worrying and I know some big ones.

SW blows.......cramped seating, rude staff, that stupid bag of peanuts, shall I go on? This airline is the 'Wal-Mart of the sky'..............

I hate the new boarding system. If you don't have a fast computer and internet connection you are out of luck. I checked in within the first 30 seconds and ended up with A37. Everyone that needs or wants an isle seat must be ready 24hrs in advance by their computer - ridiculous. You also might want to upgrade to ultra high speed fiber optic internet connection to beat the rush - if you can afford it. Or buy a high fare ticket - either way now it costs more to fly in comfort. The old system had it's problems, but anyone that really wanted a good seat could get one if they invested some time showing up early to the airport. Now it takes cash and if you don't have it you might be better off in an assigned seat on another airline.

I do a lot of business flying. I'm on my second companion pass. Every business flyer to whom i have spoken prefers your old policy of allowing families with children four and under to board first. Knowing where the families with children are sitting allows subsequent passengers to select a seat away from the children if that is their preference. I have seen several unhappy flyers who boarded first and selected the emergency row seats dismayed by having crying babies seated directly in front of or behind them when children board at the end of the Group A.

Your new policy of boarding by numbers within the A, B, and C categories unintentionally disadvantages your best customers, those flying with a person on a companion pass or a rapid rewards ticket. The companion pass and rapid reward ticket holder must have a separate confirmation number from the primary flyer. By the time you log in a second confirmation number for the companion several numbers within the category have been issued resulting in the primary flyer and the companion being in separate boarding numerical groups. Your policy should be amended to allow the companion to board with the primary flyer, even though their number may be a little higher.

I recently used my companion pass and 6 rapid rewards tickets to fly the family from Sacramento to Orlando and return. Even though we started the boarding pass log in process exactly 24 hours prior to departure the family was separated because each person had their own confirmation number and other numbers were assigned between each log in.

If you're going to start giving the better seats to those who pay more for their seats instead of the "cattle call" method that has been used forever, you should just do like the other airlines and have assigned seats to begin with.

I think the logic that went into this change will have a significant impact on those who will fly with Southwest. I hate to say it, but a lot of people will start to fly other airlines if they have to pay more for a decent seat.

Sorry, but i'll have to deal with JetBlue, at least there i may pay a little more for my seat, but i'll also have more comfort with the additional legroom.

I have always enjoyed flying Southwest. They have gotten me home during college and around the country on business. I am not pleased with their new changes. I have enjoyed online check-in and appreciated the ease of online reservations compared with other airlines. But I refuse to pay 3 times the lowest fare, just so I can have priority seating and a free drink. I think most people will be standing around the gates anyway waiting for their group to pop up on the screen.

Hooray to the people who have a company or the means to purchase the more expensive rates and the perks that come along with it. But I have chosen Southwest as my carrier because it has made its fares affordable and available to many. If their business customers are so numerous perhaps they can offer a business online route to major cities. I can fly more often and to a greater number of destinations with Southwest, and I hope to continue to do so. But these changes may make it hard to ignore their competitors.

1. I'd like to echo Duwayne's point regarding the Companion pass. Although, the seat next to the primary passenger can be 'saved' for the companion by the first person to board, so I don't see it as a complete disaster.

2. The screens that indicate which row to line up in (A 1-30 for example) can be used more effectively. When these passengers are being asked to board, by the too-quiet announcement, why not have this screen flash as a visual aid to the hearing impaired?

3. Although I feel 'rewarded' for my frequent flights as I am on the 'A-list', I do feel for families and those that attempt to get an A 24 hours in advance and fail to do so. I think many people are over-reacting, thinking they definitely will not get an A, so they should try it before they dismiss.

Also, I am concerned that the large number of Awards I have collected may be difficult to use based on others experiences detailed in this blog. Time will tell, but I will be frustrated if the previous flexibility in using awards is no longer available.

4. Price vs A passes has become a serious concern for many fliers, it would seem. But, as long as Southwest flights are less expensive than competitors, I see Southwest remaining to be popular. People need to get from A to B, they don't need all the additional entertainment - they can bring that themselves.

5. I imagine time and experience will help educate people on the new boarding system, but of the few times I have flown recently, I've been amused at the number of people who line up, just after the announcement has been made to let the passengers know they do not need to line up yet. People watching is forever fascinating.

Overall I've no issues with the new process, but as mentioned, I think I am perhaps one of the lucky few who will take advantage of the A-list. I'd suggest people look to this enhancement as something they too can acquire if they make Southwest their primary airline of choice over the next 12 months - which I am sure is part of the marketing idea behind the scheme.

For me Southwest does the job. It gets me to where I am going. People love to complain, and they do not like change. They also rarely chose to look on the positive side of change.

I'm infuriated.

I bought a ticket 6 days before you made this announcement under the assumption that I would be eligible to board the plane before anyone else as long as I checked in first. This is critical to me, because at 6'11", I can barely squeeze into your regular seats. I now find out that I have to pay an extra $400 (more than double) to qualify. If I had known this, I would not have purchased a non-refundable ticket.

The ethical way of making this change would be to have it take effect in several months, not immediately.

There is flat out no reason to fly Southwest any more. Good riddance.

Does this mean that business travelers will get to board at the same time as my wife, who got early boarding once because she was the stewardesses former hairstylist?

Herb/Gary/Southwest in general,

Facts:
1. I am a businessman
2. I travel for work (50 round trip flights/year)
3. My primary residence is in Phoenix
4. I own LUV

Feelings: I have flown SWA almost exclusively for many years, why:
1. Safety Record- your planes don't fall out of the sky
2. Simplicity- go to one website, yours, buy fare, print pass, go
3. Competence- your pilots are good and attendants friendly
4. Cost- Prices are low and consistent and rarely charge for flight changes
5. Consistency- You don't have delays/overbookings/cancelations

You are now causing me great concern.

KISS- Keep It Simple

I don't need rewards programs
I don't need a letter and numbers seating system
I don't need to be boarded before families with kids
I don't need food or beverages on the flight

ALL I NEED IS TO GET TO MY CLIENT AND BACK TO MY FAMILY SAFELY AND ON TIME. THAT IS IT.

From my perspective, your customer, you are fixing something that was not broken.

P.S. I don't want to see you become a HBS case study on what not to do.

I very much enjoy Southwest's reliability and positive attitude. I have been willing to overlook the lack of amenities (audio, video, no reserved seats) in the past. No more, however. With separating people into classes - you are like other airlines now. Why not go all the way and assign seats? Your fares are no longer lower than the competition. So, what incentive do I have to fly with you? Let me put it this way - I used to go to you first when I flew. Now - I will look to Jetblue, and Frontier first. If they do not go nonstop to where I want to go - I will look at all other airlines equally - including yours. Whoever has the best schedule/price wins. In case of ties - I will go with getting an assigned seat. Thank you for your time.

Everyone is entitled to their opinions. That's why we have this forum here. So everyone can chat...good and bad. But come on folks! Some of you are being down right rude, and I take offense to that. The Employees here at SWA have faith in our Leaders. Afterall, they have been hand picked by the Leaders before. If our company has made a mistake, they would "own" up to it and "fix" it. But I do not believe that's the case...no mistake made here. Ya know, most people don't call management to compliment a job well done. But have an employee make a mistake, or someone's food order be wrong etc. in any business, you can believe management will be recieving a phone call. Of course you are going to hear more negative comments. Does the phrase "squeeky wheel gets the grease" come to mind? Many, and I would bet most, are complaining and have not even tried the new boarding process. They do not even fully understand it. That is apparent by their comments. If you are a parent, and concerned about family boarding, don't be. You can check in online early as well. No one is forcing you not to check in online. You will be taken care of. If you are most concerned about boarding first to get that coveted "extra leg space" seat(s) then you can simply get the business or check in early online. When I travel, I really don't mind where I sit. If I'm traveling with my 2 year old, all I care about is that he and I have a seat together. We are not traveling overseas. I'm not going to be on that plane for hours and hours and hours. So it really doesn't matter. I just want to get to my destination SAFELY! That is my only concern. So if I sit in the middle seat....so what. That seat is the same size seat as the others.
Southwest is my company! I'm proud to be an Employee! You will probably never see me. I'm not a "frontline" employee. But my feelings have been hurt by some rude comments on here. We are a company. We have job security, and that's a beautiful thing! I have changed the way I live now. My daughter now drives my Dodge Durango to school now and I drive her little peppy 4 cylinder to work....yep, my teen drives my vehicle, and I drive hers. Why? FUEL! We have had to adjust some things around for our budget. When you have a long commute, it gets very pricey. Imagine the fuel our jets use. Now imagine you had to figure a way to balance your monthly budget with the way fuel prices have increased. How would you do it? Other airlines did it at the expense of their employees. I know because my husband works for one of the other airlines. He took a cut in pay and benefits. That was/is very very hard on us. We do not want that here! I hope you, the flying public, do not want that for us either. We work hard. We work as efficiently as we can. Sometimes, you just have to try other things. And if a few people choose (key word) to pay a little more, while the rest get great prices, than that's a win-win situation isn't it? If price is not an issue, then you can help us by paying a few bucks more. I know our prices for our business select is NO WHERE NEAR a "first class" ticket price on other carriers. You still get first class service no matter what seat you are in on SWA. Our Customers' treatment is, and always will be the same great service.

I'm sorry I have rambled on here....and almost written a book. But I take these comments to heart. All that we ask, is before you say we "blow" you should first at least try it. And then you can offer some constructive criticism if need be. You can also offer a compliment if need be.
Let's be thanful that we live in a country where we do have the freedom to fly, the freedom to complain or compliment. Many places you cannot. Let's be thankful for our many friends and family and our armed forces men and women who will not be with their families this holiday to give us these freedoms, and hopefully to allow others around the world to have the same.
**stepping down from soap box**

I share Charlie R's sentiments. Despite qualifying for the Ã

My young, ages 9 and 12 (adult!!!), grandchildren will be flying to visit me without an adult. It sounds as if they could easily be separated as they board the nonstop flight. If this is true, I will have to cancel their tickets and get new ones on an airline which reserves seats. Does anyone have any suggestions? I have never even looked at airlines other than SW, but I guess now I will have to do so when I buy tickets.

When is Southwest going to offer flights to the west coast from Palm Beach that doesn't involve 2 stops each way? I would love to see a flight to Las Vegas or Phoenix from Palm Beach to get to west coast cities. My choice is to drive 2 hours to Fort Lauderdale or fly another airline from PBI.

I have experienced the new boarding procedures and I have no problems with it once it gets in sync and your gate agents follow the established protocol.

That being said, I am simply floored by your new pricing structure. In the past 48 hours, the company I work for (in Phoenix) has removed Southwest from its "preferred" list of airlines because the new pricing structure is unbelievable. As one of the travel coordinators for my company, I am perplexed as to the justification for the sudden sticker shock.

Even for personal travel, your pricing has certainly excluded me. That ticket from Phoenix to Las Vegas that was running $118 (which included fees and taxes) two months ago is now $239 even if I book four months in advance. You are going to have to show me hard evidence that your costs have doubled in order to justify those increases. At $239, I can add another $80 and fly JetBlue to NYC.

You have said you are trying to appeal to the business traveler. Did you run any of these changes in front of focus groups, because if you had, I doubt you would have instituted the pricing structure. I have been coordinating travel on the corporate level for about 20 years now and every business traveler I know falls into one of two camps: the "bargain hunter" and the "upgrader."

The first is going to fly the cheapest flight they can get in order to save money for the bottom line. They don't particularly care that they are in boarding group B or C. They just know that $118 from Phoenix to Orange County is a good buy. But now, that flight is $239 and they can now go to USAir which is offering the same routing for $118. Your pricing structure has driven off the "bargain hunter" businessperson into the arms of another airline, not to mention us Average Joe's who chose Southwest because of the cheap fares regardless of the time of day.

The "Upgrader" flies coach on Delta/United/American/etc. in hopes they can hit the upgrade elite status so that they have a very good change of moving up from coach to Business Class or First Class. It is there that they can open up the laptop and have room to actually do some work. The upgrade on Southwest is that you get on the plane first and you get a free cocktail. But, your seat will always come with the same pitch and width. My travelers want the chance to move up and get a better seat, not a free cocktail. Getting on the airplane first is unimportant because they have an assigned seat. So, Southwest is now chasing them away, too, and the arms of another airline is ready to accept them.

In the video above, there are plenty of nods about how Southwest just HAS to change. But you never really state why. SW is one of the few profitable airlines with a business model that worked when Northwest Airlines was keeping people trapped on the tarmac in Detroit for 10-12 hours. Why does something that isn't broken need fixing? You don't need to change for the sake of change.

So, with fares higher than other airlines, no real "upgrades" per se, and the death of a business model that worked, please let me know why I or my corporate travelers should fly SWA?

I don't understand what the problem is.....All the families with kids and everybody else who is crying - YOU WANT A DEFINITE "A" GROUP??? Easy PAY FOR IT!!!! Having children does not entitle you to the bulkhead seat everytime you fly. You need extra time boarding?? Then you should need extra time deplaning BUT NOOOOO. You grab your kids and the carry seat and the rolling packpacks and set it up in the gangway as all the rest of the passengers are trying to exit. Do you care???? Apparently not.

Your concern should be sitting all together. With the new boarding process your family still gets to sit together!! JUST NOT IN THE FIRST 10 or 15 ROWS! TOO BAD! Get on the computer with the rest of us and try for an "A" list OR just pay for it.

Waaaa Waaaa you all sound like a bunch of spoiled brats. This is a business. Pay or get out of the way.

Heard on CNN yesterday that Southwest flew more passengers in the first 8 months of this year than any other airline in the world ...69 MILLION!!!! Management at SW must know a little bit more on how best to operate their business than all of us put together. They've been an outstanding airline in the past, and I believe they will continue to be - with or without a couple hundred spoiled, whiney passengers. Besides, if the new proceedures need tweaking, I'm sure Southwest will tweak.

I have faith in an airline that has proven fiscal responsiibility AND an exemplary safety record. When I fly the legacies I feel like I'm paying twice...once in my tax dollars to bail them out from bankruptcy and then again for the cost of the ticket.

Reality vs. Expectations?
1. I am a Road warrior-travel most every week
2. I fly WN most of the time. 200 RR credits/year and NO WN credit card.
3. I "earn" lots of RR tickets and Companion passes/annually
4. I am in control of who I fly and when.
5. I spend my companies money like it was my own
6. I used to buy lots of "Ding Fares"
7. WN Gate Agents sleep in Bath Tubs-no spine!
8. New Boarding Process is a "Gaggle"
9. I am "A-lister"-A-16-20 most every flight.
10. Won't buy Business Select! Are you nuts!
11. Just booked 2 Frontier Flights and UA for December-Jan 08
12. You lost my luggage last week again for 48 hours-hell UA does it all the time so why not fly them!
13. Yes, Lucky 13, WN isn't cheaper any more!

Desert ranger....

SOUTHWEST IS STILL CHEAPER THAN FRONTIER AND UA!!!

I flew on Monday, Nov. 12th and was very upset with the sitting. As always I was on website as soon as possibly to get boarding pass. I was shocked to be B, I have never been B. I was traveling with my son and his 8 month old baby and he could not board until all 60 A had board, what airlines does that, and other family could not board until A had.

We have had MANY free tickets with SW with my husband business and his flying. So this an outrage to be treated this way.

Oh I know that SW said on MSNBC that this will pass and the people will get used to it since they are going to be aiming for business travel people. The CEO said will make millions more money. It is always about MONEY and lining the CEO and board pockets so they can have many BIGGER HOMES and CARS.

I am sure SW does not care or will will response to this message, beside what would they say, nothing is going to change. .

My husband has check with Alaska Airlines to see about traveling with them when possible
.
Very upset SW traveler.

Oops - Gary...Gary...Gary

I have flown Southwest almost exclusively (98% of the time) in the last 8 years, logging more than 300 flights.

This one is probably going to cost you a lot of loyal passengers, although there really aren't a lot of other decent options in markets like Manchester. If you are going to change the old policy of first come first served, why not just assign seats?

Your system is too complicated and it clashes with Southwest's established "everyone is equal" culture. It also pits passengers against one another because a first boarder will be trying to block out the seats next to them waiting for their traveling partners (who aren't A-listers).

What happens to a child or companion (hey - a companion pass holder is one of your best customers) who can't board with the A-lister?

You didn't think this one through - the best course would be to admit a mistake and either go back to first come first served, or start giving out assigned seats.

The more you try to fix it, the more complex it will become and the more consternation it will create.

Switch to assigned seats or go back to first come first served! Gee - I still like the plastic boarding cards - because hacks on a computer couldn't get ahead of me.

Finally, if you are going to charge extra to board first, let me select my seat! I should at least know what I am buying before I pay you. Check out the Northwest web site - they still don't have it figured out right since you can't assign all the seats at the same time on a multiple leg flight, but at least you know what you are paying for, when you upgrade to an aisle seat 24 hours before the flight.

This is a dramatic culture change, and the many will end up abandoning the airline while the few, with large expense accounts, probably won't make up for the lost revenue.

Even working on the financial numbers, this one doesn't make sense. You didn't properly calculate the revenue that you will loose from loyal passengers looking elsewhere.

Myself, I think that these new changes to boarding and fares show that SWA is working towards creative new approaches to the changing times and rising costs of air travel. There are now a wider range of fare options, and the whole "Business Select" concept provides a brilliant alternative for those who really, really want to board first.

As for complaints about the new priority boarding for families, since these folks get to board following the A group, I think it's hugely unlikely that families will find themselves separated. And in my many years of flying Southwest, I have found passengers to be pretty accomodating and easy-going. I sincerely do not think that many would balk when asked to make some room so that your children can sit near you.

I know that we can sometimes be reluctant when it comes to change. But it seems to me that SWA is thinking outside of the box here (that ol' "coloring outside of the lines" is still being encouraged) and coming up with new approaches to saving ground time, and thus keeping fares as low as they can.

Way to go, Gary. I applaud you and all of the creative People of Southwest Airlines!

PERTAINING TO THE COMMENT OF THE FEMALE WHO WAS ASKED TO ADJUST HER CLOTHING ATTIRE.......KUDOS TO YOU SOUTHWEST AND THE "GENTLEMEN" WHO REQUESTED IT......THIS CAME FROM A "MALE" WHICH WAS A SURPRISE TO EVERYONE I'M SURE, BUT EVERYONE SEEMS TO FORGET ONE BIG FACT..........

BEFORE THAT LADY EVEN ATTEMPTED TO PULL THAT "MINI" DOWN FURTHER, HAVE YOU EVEN THOUGHT ABOUT HER SEATING???????? FOLKS, WHEN SHE SAT DOWN, ALL THAT WAS ON THE SEAT WAS HER "BOTTOM" AND I'LL BE NICE IN ADDRESSING THIS....FROM FRONT TO BACK, HER "BOTTOM".............NOW, NO ONE KNOWS IF SHE WAS WEARING UNDERGARMENTS OR NOT, BUT, GERMS ARE GERMS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...WHY WOULD ANYONE WANT TO TAKE A CHANCE TO SIT AFTER HER, WHEN SHE COULD HAVE VERY WELL CONTAMINATED THE SEAT WITH "WHATEVER"...THEN SHE HAD THE NERVE TO EXSPECT AN APOLOGY? GIVE ME A BREAK.......SHE WAS THE ONE SPREADING HER "PERSONAL HYGIENE GERMS" AND THAT IS TOTALLY UNEXCEPTABLE......THERE ARE PEOPLE AROUND, KIDS WHO'S LITTLE HANDS MAY TOUCH THAT SEAT AFTER HER AND CATCH WHATEVER........I WAS FLOORED WHEN I FIRST READ ABOUT IT BECAUSE I THOUGHT IT WAS TOTALLY "UN SANITARY", THEN SHE EXSPECTS THE APOLOGY........WELL, UNLESS SOUTHWEST SCRUBBED HER SEAT WITH CLORAX WHERE DOES THAT LEAVE US....SOUTHWEST DID RIGHT FOR ASKING HER TO ADJUST HER "STYLE." SHE SHOULD NOT SPREAD "WHATEVER" FROM WHAT "UNDER" TO EVERYONE WHO COMES IN CONTACT WITH THAT SEAT....(GOSH, WHERE IS OSHA WHEN YOU NEED THEM)...SWA SHOULD NOT HAVE APOLOGIZE TO HER, AND INSTEAD SHOULD HAVE MADE HER GRAB A BUCKET AND CLORAX AND CLEAN UP HER GERMS........GREAT JOB SOUTHWEST ON ADDRESSING THIS ISSUE............I GUESS SHE TOOK THE TERM "BOTTOMS UP" LITTERALLY.............

Just spent an interesting week on a business trip and got to witness the confusion in 4 different airports (SEA, PHX, LAX and SLC). You've taken a nice simple system and made it a complicated mess with little signs everywhere and those rotating ABC triangles. So what's actually the A line looks like the C line from a different angle.

At SLC, there were so many signs everywhere I ended up standing in a line for the wrong gate, then when I realized my error and merged into my numerical position (A43) the gate agent reprimanded me for not standing in line earlier. I thought the whole point of this was to reduce standing in line??? Under the old system, I never even bothered standing in line if I had an A pass, I would just sit until the A's started boarding and then tag along at the end.

Also noted with interest the new policy of sandwiching the families with toddlers between the A and the B groups ... very thankful my family of 7 will not have to endure what is sure to be a horrifying Thanksgiving travel week with you guys. Of course I am biased here, but I really think the preboarding of families with toddlers makes sense for two reasons: 1) It is much easier to have parents and kids sitting together; 2) It makes it easier for the A group to avoid sitting next to where the kids are stationed.

Our family normally flies a few trips a year on SWA, although last time we flew Alaskan because it was actually cheaper to go with them despite the fact that my wife could have flown free on my SWA Companion Pass. Your competitive fares have already been slipping; now you can bet on future flights we will give preference to airlines that can ensure we sit together as a family.

Please guys, either go back to the old format or just go with reserved seats. This current situation is a needlessly complex mess.

People here seem to be under the illusion that fares can remain the
same even though fuel prices have doubled. Get real, people. Extra
money has to come from somewhere. Would you rather pay all the extra
on your tickets or would you rather have business travelers carry most
of the increase?

You know and I know that we buy the cheapest tickets we can find.
Southwest knows it too. Southwest is creatively attempting to keep
leisure fares down as much as possible in the face of high fuel
prices. Cut them some slacK: they are doing it for your own good.

I'd rather be able to afford a flight as a "second-class citizen" then
to have to stay home because I couldn't afford to travel on the
"everyone is equal" airline. The latter is not what I'd call "Freedom
to Fly".

Barbara Watson wrote: "For many of us, it's not about being thrifty;
it's about whether we can afford to fly at all." To Barbara I say:
That is exactly why Business Select is your friend, not your enemy.
Money collected from Business Select customers is money that doesn't
have to come out of your pocket. That money has to come from
somewhere.

People who are complaining about A's no longer being affordable would
be the first ones to complain about a massive increase in leisure
fares in the absence of a program like Business Select. They need to
get a grip on financial reality. The status quo is not an option with
oil at $98. It's just not.

On another subject, Gale Thomssen complained about limited
availability and vowed to switch airlines. Gale, do you have any idea
how difficult it has become to redeem a saver award on any airline
other than Southwest or JetBlue? It's a scandal. We'd always like
better availability, especially on Fridays and Sundays, but
Southwest's award tickets are the most usable in the industry. Ask
anyone at flyertalk.com and they'll tell you the same. One other
suggestion: award availability sometimes improves in the last week or
so before a flight. But for Thanksgiving and Christmas you're not
going to get the peak travel dates you want.

Carolyn K,

There is an easy solution to your problem. You can check them in 24 hrs in advance online and easily get an a or b boarding pass. Even if they check in at the airport and get a c boarding pass a flight attendant can ask for 2 people to volunteer to move so that the kids can sit together.

Zach K,

I don't know where you are getting your fares from but I just looked at southwest.com and the fare from phx to vegas with 14 days in advance is STILL $59 each way. Maybe you were looking at us airways' website when you saw the 239 roundtrip fare.

Correction on my last post: Phx to ORANGE COUNTY is only $59 each way. You just have to look at different dates and times...

I, too, am a faithful Southwest passenger, although not enough of a frequent flyer to get "special status."

Flying Southwest is a trade-off--you trade some convenience for efficiency and price. I believe that most frequent flyers are savvy enough to check in online and get a good boarding pass. Most people that fly have access to the internet. Families with small children can already board early. When we have travelled long distances with a group, we were able to switch around at the first stop and sit with our group. My motto is " if it ain't broke, don't fix it!"

To Gary Kelly,
My wife is flying on Southwest from ABQ to Seattle to visit her sister for Thanksgiving. We appreciate all you and your team does to get us from point A to point B in a safe and comfortable manner. In order to help your passengers and your team, I would like to talk about the loading experience and propose a few modifications.

First, there are elderly passengers who do not take advantage of your pre-boarding option. I think the flying experience of your passengers would be more positive if one or more of your people in the loading area would invite the people they think appropriate to pre-board. I think this would streamline the loading and enable the pre-boaders to load in a less stressful environment. This would also prevent passengers who have trouble climbing over other passengers to get to their seat.

Second, many of the pre-boaders are families with children. My personal experience has demonstrated that there are families who are not eligible for pre-boarding but they use it anyway. I think your people could educate us, as passengers, to insure the pre-boaders are appropriate.
Also, related to this issue, if you were to assign a seating area to those families with very young children (infants and toddlers for example), I think it would be a more positive flying experience for your passengers.

We appreciate your hard work. Thank you for your thoughtful consideration.

Regards,

DJ

For the people who are saying "just pay the extra fare": I priced the extra fare for my flight, and it was double the fare I paid expecting just the old system with the added numbers. There is no way Southwest can justify this. There are 6 bulkhead seats and 4 exit row seats with extra leg room, but up to 15 tickets are sold at the "business select" fares. This means that as many as 5 people may pay twice as much for no benefit. This is a fraud.

The new SWA business plan to create a pay-more-or-go-to-the-back-of-the-line system of boarding has just erased my 20-year-old customer loyalty to the airline. I will now look only for the cheapest-and-most-direct flight that I can find when I travel. The only U.S. airline that was different isn't so different anymore.

I have no problem with the new system. 6 flights since the change.. I actually enjoyed the boarding process...SWA need not worry, at least with SWA the plane gets you there on time...

We will wave to those who choose to change airlines when our plane leaves the gate and you are still waiting to board your new found airline because you did not like the new system...

You will all be back in time!

Debi Ferguson writes..."I flew on Monday, Nov. 12th and was very upset with the sitting. As always I was on website as soon as possibly to get boarding pass. I was shocked to be B, I have never been B. I was traveling with my son and his 8 month old baby and he could not board until all 60 A had board, what airlines does that, and other family could not board until A had."

My questions - did you sit together? Did you pay and outrageous price for your ticket? If you required extra time boarding, were you willing to wait until the other passengers deplaned before exiting the plane yourselves? The answers, I suspect are 1) YES, 2) NO and 3) NO.

Kjarrett write "People who are complaining about AÃ

The new boarding procedure - brilliant!! The new Business Select program - FANTASTICALLY BRILLIANT!!! I used to fly you ALL the time, but it just got to be too much of a hassle for boarding. I am now back and using your business Select program. It's great to be back - thanks southwest!
BTW - sure wish you would get direct flights from Hobby to New York City back again - when you had the codeshare with ATA - I flew it almost everyweek for awhile. I heard ATA discontinued it 'cause they thought they were competing wiht Jet Blue - I assure you - they were not competing with Jet Blue. But - whatever the reason - please bring back a direct flight from Hobby to New york City!!! LUV ya!

Kyla Ebbert is in this monthÃ

Southwest employees must take charge at the gates. Make people abide by the rules. I've seen people sit in chairs and say i'm in line(no way) stand like everyone else. Handdicapped solution (must have doctors note) these people get on first and jump off (no sign of medical condition) seen it many times. Plus we do not need a family of mom, dad, aunts, uncles, grandparents to help with the baby. please address these things.

i like the A seating change but, still keep it as first come first serve, and go back to the old pricing selections. at first glance it makes you want to check out other airlines for cheaper filghts plus, get you seat assigned right away and that way there is no need to go online 24 hours in advance,.think about it!

I HATE the new seating!!! A few weeks ago I flew twice with my 5 yr old daughter and 8 yr old son. Not knowing that the new pre-board restriction was in effect I automatically went to the pre-board and upon boarding was informed that we did not meet the requirements for pre-board, and my 5 yr old was too old to board between A & B. So we went to the END OF "C". when we got on the plane their were not any seats together. Someone was kind enough to move so that I could sit with my 2 children....in the last seat infront of the bathroom!

Now on the return flight we were coming from a place that did not have internet service, so needless to say we were automatically "c" group. When we boarded the plane this time NO ONE WOULD GIVE UP THEIR SEAT so that I could sit with my 2 children. The flight attendents even offered a free cocktail to anyone that would move and no one offered. I Watched people actually cover up their faces pretending not to realize what was happening.

I was then told that there was an empty seat in the back of the plane for my 8 year old and one in the front for my 5 yr old and one in the middle of the plane for me. ARE YOU KIDDING ME????? Someone really expected my 5 year old daughter to sit in the front of the plane with strangers? With this of course so started to cry....she is FIVE!!!! So I said that I would not allow this, finally the flight attendant asked someone to move and I was able to sit with my 5 yr old while my 8 yr old had to sit by himself. The witch of a woman sitting in the seat mext to me would not give up her seat to allow my son to sit with his mother. (Because her husband was in the seat across the way--what a joke, she does not want to sit without her husband, but it's ok for my son to sit without his mom).

I am a frequent flyer, and have ALWAYS flown SW, but I am MAD!!! We are flying again tomorrow on a 7:00a.m. flight and I have to get up this morning and print my boarding passes right away to make sure that I will not be separated from my children again. But what is going to happen on my return flight????? Again, I will be in "C" (no internet).

I can not stress enough the importance of pre-broad with children!

I'm currently a contractor for Southwest, so I fly on the company's dime and wait until the very end of the boarding process before I hit the jetway so that Customers get the best seats. This gives a me a great opportunity to see the pros and cons of the new boarding system as well as a score a middle seat on every leg of the flight :)

From what I've witnessed I've seen a few dramatic shifts in passenger attitudes and activities prior to boarding....

-Passengers are now able to sit down and relax before boarding. No more folks camped out for an hour waiting in line just to secure their spot.
-In upgraded gate areas - families are enjoying the redesigned "family areas" to relax and talk. Upgraded comfy chairs with power sources are fantastic...I heard one guy mention "if I had seats like this I think I might actually come earlier" - wow!
-The process seems a little confusing for some who either haven't flown Southwest in a while or are new flyers. Gate agent announcements seem to reduce the confusion but some more visual descriptors of the process at the gate might be helpful.
-There is a concern that folks may not be exactly where they should be in line, say an A29 is lined up before an A4. I'm sure this process will be tweaked, or peer pressure will force folks to find their right spot in line.

I think the biggest gain for us as Customers is the fact that we can use that time before boarding to eat, sleep, or work unlike in the old system where we had to just wait in line to secure our spot. Additionally, the new Business Select fares may sound a bit elitist - but heck, with oil at $90 a barrel it's going to be very hard for Southwest to keep it's prices down - just like an other airline. Letting a few pay extra to board earlier actually keeps the fares lower for the rest of us.

At the end of the day the boarding process is designed to react to Customers concerns that they were tired of waiting in line. The revised fare options allows Southwest to remain competitive by offsetting rising fuel prices by allowing Customers that wanted additional perks - like being first in line - to pay for that privilege.

Finally, before and after you you board that plane you're still surrounded by the best Customer service in the industry. Southwest keeps me happy, even when I have the last seat which puts me between the two largest fliers on the flight. They have attendants that actually like their jobs; they sing, they clap, they make jokes. You won't find positive attitudes like that on any other airline. - hands down. You have a problem with a flight and you call Reservations, guess what, you're not confronted with a confusing phone-tree queue, you get connected to a real person who really cares. Again - wow - try that with any other airline. They keep it simple and they keep it nice.

For those that are concerned, try out the changes, see what you like, what you don't like, and voice your thoughts. Happy flying!

After reading these blogs, I felt compelled to add my comments. I've been a Rapid Rewards member since 1996 and fly exclusively on Southwest. When the number system was implemented as a pilot at the San Antonio, TX airport, it went very smoothly and I supported it 100%. The SW representatives explained it very thoroughly and enforced the numerical boarding process. I would check-in online and have number A 1-5 99% of the time. Now I'm on the "A" list and the first time I flew out of El Paso on a return flight to San Antonio, it was chaotic! I arrived at the airport on Friday 11/16 with my A-List number A25, approximately 2 hours early. There was not a vacant seat to be found so I stood with dozens of other people. Seats had been removed to provide space for the "make-shift" lines, which resulted in reduced seating in all waiting areas. Where are the new seating areas that have been advertised? I hope this will be corrected in the near future.

Prior to my flight (which was late), I observed the boarding process for another flight. Many of the passengers appeared to be lost and were in the wrong line. The SW Representative didn't do a very good job explaining the process and I saw people merge into the lines out of sequence. The SW representative that worked my flight explained it very well, and with my A25 I was the 35th passenger to board in El Paso. I'll be flying over the Christmas holidays on a RR's ticket and there is no telling what number boarding pass I'll get!

My observation is that all SW staff should have visited the San Antonio Airport to observe their operation of the numerical system; and the waiting areas should have been redesigned, prior to implementation. Passengers should not be able to buy their way onto the A-List. It should be based on the number of flights - not the price of the tickets. Southwest Airlines owes it's success to the frequent flyers - not the ones with the deepest pockets. If priority is going to be given, it should be given to these frequent flyers.

I hate your seating policy. I fly your airline when I have no other choice. Why you dont learn from JetBlue how to serve your customers.

You know, whether I'm an A or a C boarder, somehow I seem to arrive at the same time. And like you say, drybar, on time!

I refuse to purchase any more SWA tickets until the system is changed back. I believe we deserve a full REFUND on any tickets we have already purchased. My tickets are no longer worth what I paid for them. UNBELIEVABLE that you would install this program, screwing over people retroactively.

I think it's ironic that you have implemented business fares. Company travel policies will still require that their employees book the lowest fare possible - that means most of your business travelers won't be able to take advantage of the business traveler perks you offer (more rapid rewards, free drink, preboarding, etc.).

I think the business fares will end up being a big fat goose egg.

Many times, businesses take the risk of alienating their current customers with the hope of attracting new ones. History seems to indicate that this doesn't always pay off.

I never had any problem with the system of open seating. It seemed kind of funny the first time, but then I was okay with it. The bottom line was that I soon found that I was able to get better seats.

It seems to me that this system was designed to appeal to travel columnists instead of Southwest's current customers. I will see it first hand soon enough.

Just an FYI.......
That Ã

NEW BOARDING PROCEEDURE--USED IT FOR THE FIRST TIME--AS EXPECTED SEVERAL PASSENGERS "VIOLATED" THE LINE W/NO ONE FROM SOUTHWEST "POLICING" THE LINE-UP --WILL JUST GET WORSE AS MORE REALIZE THE LINEUP MEANS LITTLE OR NOTHING.
AS LONG AS SOUTHWEST IS GOING IN THIS DIRECTION--IT SEEMS KIND OF SILLY TO GIVE ME A "BOARDING NUMBER"
WHY DON"T YOU GO ALL THE WAY AND EITHER:
PROVIDE ME W/AN ASSIGNED SEAT OR AT TIME I BOOK (IF ON LINE) SHOW ME THE SEATING CONFIGURATION OF THE PLANE (AS OTHERS DO) AND ALLOW ME TO SELECT THE SEAT(S) W/ MY MOUSE.
U.S. AIRLINES STILL MAKE A MESS OF BOARDING-I USED TO TRAVEL INTERNATIONALLY AND THE SYSTEM IN PLACE IN EUROPE MADE A LOT OF SENSE AND WORKED GREAT!! THE CHECK-IN AT THE GATE ALLOWED YOU TO PRESENT YOUR PASS AS YOU ARRIVED--YOU WERE THEN ALLOWED INSIDE A SEATING/BOARDING CORRAL AND WHEN BOARDING WAS ANNOUNCED EVERYONE SIMPLY FILED ON THE PLANE--NO LAST MINUTE CONFUSION/DELAY AS THE ATTENDANTS TRIED TO "CHECK" EVERYONE IN AT THE LAST MINUTE AS YOU WERE TRYING TO BOARD THE PLANE,BALANCE YOUR BAGS AND HAVE THE USUAL PASSENGER AHEAD OF YOU W/OUT A PASS OR SOME OTHER CONFUSION--IT TURNED THE PLANES AROUND "REALLY FAST!!"

Susan, this "Buisness" fare that you refer to is nothing new. This is the same "Refundable Anytime" fare, just under a new name. The only difference is the new option of "Business Select", which allows ANY traveller (business or otherwise, Rapid Reward customer or not) to pay a small upgrade fee to enjoy priority boarding (plus extra Rapid Reward credits and a complimentary drink). Business travellers, like anyone else, can still book under the "Wanna Get Away" fares at 14 day and 7 day advance, and in some markets 10 day and 5 day fares. So nothing has been lost here, Susan. In fact, there are more options avalable to the passenger, whether flying on business or not.

As for all this concern about family boarding, keep in mind that we all have a new alternative available: If a family with children under the age of four is travelling, and they do not wish to priority board after the A group, then they can ensure first boarding by upgrading their tickets to "Business Select". This is hardly any new "class" system that treats the business traveller any greater than the family. It is an option available to all of us.

Southwest is still offering the "freedom to fly', just with the freedom of more choices to benefit all of us.

Always flew SWA because once you learned the open seating and check-in system, it simply required a little legwork on your end to acquire a good seat of your choosing. Thought it was a great idea to implement the numbered boarding system to eliminate the need to stay put for an hour before a flight lest yoy lose your spot in line.

The latest change for prefered biz class is deeply disturbing, although not anywhere as disturbing as eliminating the family pre-boarding. My choice of SWA was always fueled by the knowledge that I would be able to avoid sitting a row away from parents with (usually) unattended children who kick seatbacks or climb onto the seatback in front of you, not to mention the lovely sound of bawling infants. That was the risk you took when purchasing assigned seats with another airline; you never knew who you'd be sitting near.

My two cents...establishing an elite biz-class that has dibs on "A" seats removes the best aspect of choosing SWA as my carrier of choice. Not pre-boarding children is a HUGE mistake. Increased fares are a fact of the economy and fuel prices. While I was always a steadfast loyal customer of SWA, I fear I have purchased my last ticket to fly with them. I think I'd rather pay an extra $50 to $100 and not have to deal with this nonsense by purchasing assigned seats on another airline.

SWA...you took a once great thing and totally destroyed it. Way to go...

I have flown exclusively Southwest for many years because the prices were right and everyone was treated the same (no first class). In the past twelve months I have flown 23 flights which is not enough to be considered one of your "A-list customers". Last week when I checked in online just minutes after the 24 hour window to check in, I received boarding pass number A-51. I assume this was due to all your preferred customers receiving their boarding pass when they made their reservation. If you no longer value my business as much as your "A-list customers" I will be forced to start shopping around my air travel, which I never did in the past. I think you should re-think your new policy allowing "A-list customers" preferential boarding.

We have homes on the East Coast (Philadelphia) and the Other Coast (Spokane, WA) and fly cross-country several times a year - often on Southwest. In general we have liked the experience, and have on a couple occasions snared boarding passes numbered in the first 5 (yeah, my wife has the internet thing timed to the nano-second). While not crazy about playing the A-B-C Line-up Game, we endured and usually were there early enough to get seats to our liking, at NO ADDITIONAL COST. You have always put the customer first, and to your credit, you fill your planes and turn them areound better that anyone we fly. But PLEASE take heed of what we, your loyal customers, are saying. Don't rock the boat for those of us that got you where you are today. Establishing "classes of boarders" goes against your founding principles. We all know what KISS means - let's admit the error in judgemant and level the playing field again.

If you buy your ticket far in advance and don't mind paying $100 if you need to cancel or change it, legacy carriers may fit you better.

If you buy your ticket within a few days of travel, and pay top fare, a legacy carriers will give you a middle seat if they are able to assign you a seat at all. Southwest wants to attract more of these high-fare late-booking passengers by guaranteeing them something other than a middle seat. The more of these passengers Southwest can attract, the lower Southwest can keep the discount fares for the rest of us.

Giving the best seats to the customers paying the lowest fares doesn't make business sense from any angle. I'm surprised the legacy carriers haven't figured this out, but they always have been slow on the uptake.

Herb, Gary & Colleen:

I'll stand up and defend your position with the best of men or women. Your thoughtful redesign is the best of both worlds. You have obviously taken a very long time to think this process through.

Most of the comments I have seen here have to do with people who fly infrequently. For those folks with the disadvantage of Orlando...my heart goes out to you...it must be difficult flying nearly any airline from the land of Mickey. However, as a recent flier of Northwest into Memphis...at a Ghastly $1493...then $116 for a change fee because I stayed one extra day, I'll take Southwest for are long as I can.

This past week, I had the pleasure of flyig on the new system. Both at full fare as well as at the new Business Select Rates. Regular full fare and early checkin still lands you a decent seat on the planes. Business Select will probably land the exit rows with all the leg room. It appears as though 1-10 are held for Business Select Clients. Since many people don't purchase these fares...then A11 has a good shot at great seats. All without a cattle call. In fact I had A55 on the return trip from Salt Lake to Baltimore and still had a middle seat in the exit row. You'll find not much of a difference than in the previous design...except the long lines.

Simply a brilliant design. Smart, Elegant, extremely well done. My compliments to all those hard working folks that put this plan in to effect.

Keep up the great work

Now if you can just connect to Rochester MN so that we can slaughter Northwest :)

Shawn Pearsall
Productive Solutions, Inc.
Fairport, New York

I am loyal Southwest customer. Love your airlines. I fly Southwest all the time. My only complaint is your lack of touch with the reality when it comes to seat assignment and boarding policy. Did you ever try taking a poll or survey from the people who actually fly your airlines instead of the pinheads who sit up on the high floors in your home office. If you ever did what I am suggesting, it will clearly tell you the following:

a) Your new boarding policy stinks. It made it worse than it used to be. Massive confusion and none of us passengers know when to board. It's a royal mess. Trust me, I have experienced it first hand.

b) We all make mistakes. Go with an (pre) assigned seat number. When I check in online, just gimmie, the dang seat number! Open seating will always, always lead to a "cow" lanes. Don't believe me, hire an independent firm and take a survey of all the passengers who fly southwest during this holiday season.

Your are running a great and customer friendly airline company. I will always be a loyal customer. For goodness sake, please wake up and stop the chaos which is being touted as the best boarding policy ever invented, IT IS NOT!

Sincerely. Ed

I just returned from a conference in Las Vegas. The conference was the Word of Mouth Marketing Association Summit. Angela Vargo with SWA was one of the breakout session panelists. As part of the breakout session Angela discussed these recent changes in the boarding process and the prioritization of frequent travelers when distributing boarding assignments.

Angela if you're reading this:

- I enjoyed the discussion session
- Thanks for the inflatable plane (my kids are grown so I gave it to another conference attendee)
- I think Southwest has made a mistake.

Not having exposure to the business case and extensive research and planning that went into this decision I'm clearly missing the drivers for this new approach. What I am aware of is the first hand exposure of the power of word of mouth marketing I experienced in the boarding line and on the plane ride home from Las Vegas. I was shocked by the volume of anger and frustration expressed by other travelers. Up and down the line one person after another expressed their disappointment and disgust for preference being given to the privileged few versus the average Joe. The decision didn't seem to fit the SWA brand. This may turn out to be a great WoM case study for a future WOMMA Summit.

I'm anxious to see the customer response over the next few weeks/months.

Jerry

While I may get a free drink and an "A" boarding pass, the biz select fares are punitive, in my opinion. How many business folks are even going to take the drink en route to an appointment?

Thirteen years of flying SWA at the exclusion of others. The party's over. I'll be shopping air travel more diligently than in the past.

The difference in a $99 web special and 'Business Select' $389 on a one-way leg is ... well ... $290. Nearly $600 RT? Business flyers are asking for this? Really? Did SWA switch business consulting firms? For everyone who thinks the new boarding is better ... you're kiddin' ... right?

You people complaining about the changes absolutely confound me. Why shouldn't the person paying more for their plane ticket expect preferred boarding? Why do you think that because you were able to plan your trip 3 months in advance and secure a ticket for a transcontinental flight for $99 that you are entitled to the absolute best seat in the airplane. Let me explain a little something about airline economics to you. Airlines don't make money by filling an airplane with $99 passengers to fly across the country. They make money by responding to the laws of supply and demand.

So you're going to go shop around for airfare now? Why in your right mind were you not doing that before? You'd rather pay more for bad service instead of flying Southwest?

Come on; get off your high horse. Southwest is tweaking its business model to cater to a demographic that they have essentially ignored, at their peril, for the past 30 years. As a business traveler, I welcome these changes. Life on the road isn't pleasant and when you're racing back to the airport to catch your flight after a day of meeting to discover that you're stuck in a middle seat in the back of the plane between two individuals who leave arm rests up because they don't fit in their own seats is not a pleasant experience.

70% of business travel revenue is generated by 10% of the flying public. Now you tell me why Southwest shouldn't target that group?

Gary,

I encourage you to give your new boarding system and business select choices a chance.
My first thought about the new system was like many others - "don't fix what ain't broken" however after a couple of runs at it, I 've come around to it.
I have chosen Business Select as my seat of choice the last two times I've flown and I'm giving it a thumbs up. As a business owner, with last minute flight schedules, I like the options that Business Select offers and the options of last minute changes without huge penalty costs. As reference, I fly a couple of times each month during the year and look forward to flying Southwest Airlines. And really, your on-time record is what really sets you apart from he other guys. No other airline can even come close as far as I'm concerned.
Thanks for the superb service.

DJ

A few insights from a former Southwest devotee:

I, like many other young professionals, am disappointed with Southwest's new selection of fares. I am not interested in "business class" perks and wastefulness and have always flown Southwest to avoid it. I have enjoyed the super low fares and am disappointed to see them jumping up so high in 2008. I will start to take my business, which is considerable, elsewhere instead of paying the much higher prices and dealing with special treatment of certain "business" passengers.

Also, I was happy when Southwest moved the families pre-boarding to in between the A and B groups since I often fly from Orlando and know how out of control pre-boarding can be. But to learn that instead of boarding behind families with children, I will now board behind spoiled businessmen? Yeah, no thanks.

The message I'm getting at is: don't change your positioning. Continue to target the younger, tech-savvy, frequent flying crowd rather than the cranky business stiffs. Because let's face it, the business stiffs have lots of choices with more attractive perks. And you're losing the customers who got you where you are today - the young professionals - with all this fluff and price hiking.

The new boarding process in reality is too complicated. People do not know where and when to line up. People do not like it, go look from behind the scenes and listen to the comments in the boarding area in a place like Las Vegas or L.A. Bring back the pld simple way please or just do it by numbers only. Maybe just preboard your Business Select people like other airlines do with boarding their first class people first so they get first choice of a seat. Thank You

Wow! I wonder what any A group boarding pass might look like!! We charge virtually all our expenditures to one credit card and as a result, use our credit points for all our travel. Since our card company has to make our reservations and then provide us a ticket rather than a "ticketless" reservation, we cannot get a boarding pass online at all. So, we arrive hours early in hopes of even a B group boarding pass, but seldom see that as the flights are so full and most travelers have gotten there boarding pass online. Even though we sometimes book months in advance, we cannot check in until arriving at the gate and seldom get to sit together. Now, the last minute "business" traveler, making his reservation weeks or even months after we made ours, is going ahead of us (and every one else). Gee, what a new twist on the caste system! Every other airline lets us choose our seat when booking, so the earlier the better. This new system is a pretty lame way of asking people to wait until the last minute or ask for the highest fare when booking so as to gouge their employer with the expense account. If I were in charge of corporate travel for a major company, I'd really think twice about having Southwest as a supplier - they're actually encouraging the bread and butter business traveler to rip off their employer. Pretty dumb move, I believe. No doubt a "bean counter" decision - someone with true sales or marketing skills would have more sense.

Those of you who are considering trying other airlines may want to take a look
at the piece of the Phoenix ABC affliate put together. The piece authored by
Lisa Fletcher. Look under the heading "Cashing in frequent flyer (SWA has Rapid Rewards) miles without sufficient advance notice.

source:www.abc15.com

The piece is called "Hidden Airline Fees".

The new boarding proceedure with the poles is the first major error I have observed at Southwest in its history.

This is a confusing big mistake.

Thank you Southwest for Business Select. I love the new boarding system. When my children were littlte and flew back and forth from S.A. to Dallas they were pre-boarded because there was no adult with them, but when I traveled with them, we never pre-boarded, we stood in line like every one else. Now I see hoards of families take advantage of this and they always want to sit up front. Then they delay the whole flight putting up the luggage and getting down the luggage with no regard or consideration for anyone else. If they want to pre-board 2 or 12 people because of one small child, then why don't they at least sit in the back so they don't delay others on the plane who can quickly grab there luggage and get off? I suggest that Southwest reserve the back of the plane for people who have issues which delay the boarding and unboarding process? Then the attendents and the passenger in need can take all the time they want getting to and from their seats during the boarding/unboarding process without delaying the other passengers. I will be flying quite often this year and I am going to continue with Southwest as long as there is business select.

Hi, I am an "A-Lister" thanks to traveling the required number of segments over the past 12 months, so I guess I should be happy about it. However, even as such, I noticed last night on my flight from Austin to Dallas that most of the boarding group from A1 to A15 was non-existent. Do these spots get saved for last-minute business fare bookings? It just seemed odd. And, most of us in line were wondering just what was up.

Although I think the basic principles behind your changes are well-intentioned, the execution leaves something to be desired. I will not be an A-Lister for long given these changes, as I will start to fly American and/or Continental more often. I think the old system was really not so bad afterall.

The result of the open system was fast seating resulting in quicker plane turnarounds and better profit for Southwest than their peers. Many folks seem to find an open seat a lot faster than matching a seat to a ticket.

Southwest has had a successful business model with loyal and satisfied customers and has been penetrating new markets successfully. Why not continue that rather than tweak a big competitive advantage during the holiday season?

The results will show up in a quarter or two - because you can't hide lost customers and profit. If the results are not positive, I expect SWA will reconsider.

I am VERY, VERY UNHAPPY with Southwest's recent Familes With Infants/Young Children Pre-boarding changes.

In October, my wife and I traveled with our two children from Mississippi to New Hampshire via BWI. One child is 2 yrs old, the other 2 MONTHS old. We were STUNNED when told we could no longer preboard and must wait - strollers, etc in tow - in the regular line and HOPE we could sit together!

I would like Gary Kelly or any other executive at Southwest to answer this: have you ever tried to board a plane with TWO children 2 and under - WITHOUT pre-boarding? Folks in line looked at us like we didn't know what we were doing. They said "you can pre-board...why are you here?". They, like we, could not believe that this convenience had been taken away from families with VERY young children. (for the record, my two kids have yet to cry or disturb anyone on any flight - they are extremely well behaved in flight...and I have seen some disruptive infants/kids while flying believe me)

And I totally agree with the person who wrote about the "fake handicap" pre-boarders. WHY would you send a family with infant(s) into the pack with strollers and all that comes with travelling with children...yet allow the voluntarily obese in wheelchairs to pre-board?? The vast majority of these folks in wheelchairs - are just FAT AND LAZY...they are NOT handicapped! Don't believe me? Try watching them walk or jog throught a given airport...only to look VERY pitiful slouching into a nearby wheelchair as they near their gate. It's in plain sight for God's sake!

My family has flown Southwest for 10 years. I have been a stockholder since 1993. I have sung the praises of this airline to all who would listen.

And now I have stopped.

We are disappointed in this company. My young family must now look to other airlines that will allow pre-boarding when travelling with very young children.

I never thought this day would come.

In the past we have used SWA on every trip we've taken from Albany, New York to our 2nd home in Tampa, Florida. Price has always been our first priority. Direct flights are the second consideration. It appears that you have lost your focus on these incentives. You have always been the airline of choice until now. For the first time in may years we now look at other carriers for the best value for our money now that you have entered the mainstream. Good Luck with your new endeavor.

Kindest Regards
Sim Adams

You need to better train your gate agents for the new boarding system. It's a great idea that should avoid passengers having to stand in line, but on a flight out of Las Vegas to Indianapolis/BWI on November 10 it didn't work worth a damn. The agent was still having people line up for A or B, leaving it to the passengers to sort themselves out in groups 1-5, etc. even though there were numbered posts where they should have been directed. It was rank confusion. I also saw folks roaming around the terminal before boarding who were perfectly mobile, but when pre-boarding was called, they were boarded as disabled. Let's cut out that nonsense too.

Congratulations !!! The new boarding system is a step in the right direction. I for one, have never understood, why a sensible person would want to sit on a dirty floor waiting, for well over an hour, just to get a decent seat on an airplane. Now all one has to do is be quick and timely to secure the coveted Ã

I have been a loyal Southwest customer for about 5 years. I live in San Francisco and go over to Oakland to get the Southwest flights I want. It was worth it for the convenience and price of Southwest. After completing the trips I already have booked for the holidays, I will be flying on United for all of my future trips. Although I often take 12-16 roundtrips in a year, I likely won't qualify for the "A" Rewards program, and if I want to get in the A group for a decent seat I will have to buy the Business Select tickets, which end up being MORE expensive than getting an ASSIGNED seat on United from a much more convenient airport. I was initially excited to hear that Southwest would start boarding by number, as I used to usually be one of the first to check in and print my boarding pass, but didn't realize that you'd be implementing other changes that would make it pretty much impossible for non-business travelers to get in the A group (as a side note, I've flown Southwest for business trips before, because of the low rates - my employers chose Southwest because of their low fares, and would not pay for the Business Select fares). I have to say I'm very disappointed in the way Southwest has chosen to change the boarding policy. I mean, this is so complicated and user-unfriendly, why not just assign seats? As of now, there is nothing convenient or advantageous for me to fly Southwest. After five years of 12-16 roundtrips per year on Southwest, I regret to say I am done. Another example of a company making "improvements" that completely eliminate things that made them great. I'm curious to know exactly how you surveyed your customers to come to this conclusion.

When are you going to start flying to Minneapolis?????

Question: What should a highly successful operation do when it outperforms its competition year after year and builds a phenomenally loyal customer base? When it consistently shows a profit while its competitors bounce in and out of bankruptcy court? When its customers share stories about the fun they had on their flights, while competitor's customers complain endlessly about how horrible their experience has been?

Southwest's answer: Change to be more like the competition!!

Anybody remember "New Coke"?? What an amazingly bad decision made by the (obviously) new leadership at Southwest. Herb, where are you?? Please come rescue your loyal customers!! I have always chosen Southwest over any other airline whenever possible, but now will have to reconsider that decision. If I have to pay more to get a seat I want, will the flight still be cheaper? If I don't pay the increased price, will I get stuck in a middle seat between the guy who smells bad and the woman with a screaming baby? Who knows? Why take the risk?

I fly Southwest because they have cheaper fares, lightning fast turnaround at the gate, rarely a canceled flight, and I get to choose my seat in person when boarding. I'm at the airport early anyways, so why not get in line and get a great seat? Now, I will lose out to those who pay extra for the right to choose first. Kind of like the "Lexus lanes" being added to highways, where those willing (and able) to pay can get a faster travel lane.

Shame on you, Southwest. Shame on Gary Kelly. And shame on Herb Kelleher for allowing this to happen before he leaves. You have a very disappointed customer, and one very upset shareholder. Apparently I'm not the only one, though, judging by the stock price since the announcement.

After trying the new boarding system in Orlando Nov 12th and being a loyal customer for last 5 years....my comment is ITS BULLS&$#.

After a Southwest Rep ( Debbie from Operations )from Dallas was asking me how I liked it, I asked , why are we all lined up and not sitting down like its professed we can. We were told to get in line and stood IN LINE for 20 mins. So much for sitting and relaxing, no different then before. When the rep said " buy another ticket and give it a chance " - I said, " Give me a free ticket and let me try it " she laughed at me and said she doesnt fly free......so you LAUGH at your customers ???

I already cancelled my Chase Southwest Card and now time to find a different airline too.

Herb please come back, your airline is going NUTS!

Has anyone taken a tally of positive comments vs. negative ones from this posting and the previous announcement posting.

As I scroll through I don't have the time to read every single one but I'd guess it's 5 to 1 negative to positive.

As a current employee I originally thought the plan was great for 2 reasons:

1. Families still sit together, which is very important, and they don't clog up the jetway waiting for their strollers to come up from the belly of the plane. Strollers are already waiting for them. Additionally, they don't sit in the front of the plane clogging up the boarding and deplaneing.

2. The numbered system is great and most love it because they don't have to stand in line.

However, this BS system is where the gripes stand. First of all, we named it BS! That's like naming your unborn baby something you know he will get teased for the rest of his life. It doesn't seem that the business community or the non-business community likes it. I know we do exhaustive research on every move we make but holy moly! We are getting blasted from all sides on every aviation web forum I've read.

I hope this was a process put in place to be easily changeable.

Instead of a free drink I will take a 10% coupon on my next flight, recovering AA here. Gary one thing I ask is please enforce a program that if you use a blue card to get on or wheel chair they need to make note and not allow these people to race off the jet, too many 35000 foot recoveries take place on every flight. All the FAs I have talked to see it all the time. One flight from MDW to PHX had 38 wheelers out of MDW in the spring, we were delayed and I can understand it, but upon arrival in PHX, the chairs were lined up and maybe 10 if they were lucky used them. Now on UAL and AA and others that have check in and assigned seating they know who these folks are and pretty much make them wait. Not sure what you can or can't do and it is sad that people do these things.
One more is when a young troop is in Uniform, let them on before anyone else, as they need to be recognized as if it were not for the troop we would not have the "Freedom to Move about the Country".
I am looking forward to seeing how things go, but am sure that the best folks on the front lines the FAs will put on that SWA charm and all will go well.

Happy Thanksgiving Gary, I am thnkful for your airline that gets me around the USA,,,,,

THANKS SWA FOR THE BUSINESS SELECT; WE ARE SO TIRED OF WAITING IN LINES FOR AN HOUR AND SOMETIMES TWO, PAYING $450 FOR A SEAT SETTING NEXT TO SOMEONE THAT PAID $100, ALL THE SILLY PREBOARDS JUMPING AHEAD OF LONG WAITERS.. SWA IS NO LONGER THE AIRLINE OF THE ECONOMY CLASS NOW WE BUSINESS TRAVELERS HAVE A BUSINESS CLASS, WE PAY MORE WE GET MORE, TAKE THAT ALL YOU CHEAP WHINERS..

What a brilliant idea the "new generation" Southwest management has come up with!! Southwest, leader of the "discount carriers" will allow me to buy a business select ticket from Nashville to Dallas, Jan 10, for the low, low price of only $229 - and that will guarantee I can be in the "A" something lineup. That almost guarantees I can get a seat near to my choosing, unless,of course, there are already passengers onboard, in which case the valued "A" boarding pass becomes of no value. On the other hand, the high priced folks at American Airlines will sell me a ticket the same day for $228 - gouging me by making me pay a dollar less and taking me non-stop as opposed to 1 or 2 stops and an airplane change on Southwest. Oh, and they'll make me go ahead and select my seat when I book the flight. Gee, I wonder if I need "new generation" thinking, applying proper algorithms and so forth to make my decision like the Southwest mangement team?? Southwest, you better "dance with the one who brung you" or you may not be dancing too much longer.

When I first heard about the new boarding system I was optimistic. I have experienced the "get there early sit on the floor and wait" for years and watched the attitudes and tempers flare with those further back in line jockeying for position. I enjoy the SWA mentality of "he who is best prepared gets the best seat" and I expected the same ideal to hold true with the new group/ number assignment system. However, I was surprised when I logged in exactly 24 hours early online, as usual, and recieved an A36 designation. Normally logging in this early would result in a number below 5. Later, at the airport, I learned about the Business Class option and the pieces fell into place.

While I do appreciate SWA's attempt at expanding the client base, my question is: is it worth alienating the budget flyers who have been the bread and butter of your business for decades? I do enjoy sitting in a seat until it is time to board, but ditch the Business business and you have it nailed.

Wow.... clearly the masses have spoken. It appears Southwest may soon displace Microsoft as the King of Backwards Innovation.

Mini DVD players are on sale and I highly recommend them for the frequent flyer in your family. $ 49.00 at Walmart Friday morning. They are great for long flights and late nights. Happy Thanksgiving to all and to all a great flight.

The biggest change that I see is the price of tickets. While people are distracted debating who gets to be first in line (like school children) ticket prices took a jump. My frequent flight BWI-PBI has almost doubled. We have traveled for years at a cost of 49.00 to 79.00 each way. Today the tickets for Jan. are available 124.00 to 172.00. The DING fare today is 81.00- 94.00 two weeks ago it was 59.00. Southwest is a great airline, and I don't mind price increases for operating expenses, but this is ridiculous.

I Just switched all my business travel to SWA and could not be happier. I live in Phx, Az and had the option to fly SWA or US Air. I have been a Chairman member with US Air for 10 yrs (100 segments per year).

After many problems this past year with US Air I decided enough is enough. I will give up a first class seat on US Air to fly SWA for the simple reason SWA gets you from point A to B on time.

As far as the new boarding process I have experienced it for 2 weeks now and the only problem I see with it is they call A 1-30 and people that might have A 30 jump the line. This problem needs to be addressed before there are fights.

As far as the new Business Select I have purchased this fare twice and think that it is a good move. For the people who travel 1-4 times per year on tickets that cost $99.00 one way for a cross country flight stop youÃ

I agree with minnemandy. Minneapolis needs Southwest. It certainly can't be hard to put 2 planes at MSP and run them to Chicago (for flights going east and south) and another to Denver, Salt Lake City, or Vegas for flights going west. The new HHH terminal is a great place to fly in and out of too.
Please Southwest, Minneapolis needs you!

Dear Sirs:
For some 35 years, I have flown Southwest almost exclusively out of Houston Hobby. I made the switch to Continental about a year ago, after having grown weary of the disproportionate number of leisure travelers on each flight. As a small business owner, traveling on business, I simply found myself part of a smaller and smaller segment of business passengers. Southwest definitely shifted it's focus toward leisure customers, all the while making changes and reducing business passenger benefits. Making the change to Continental was difficult at first, having been a loyal Southwest customer for so many years, but truthfully, the transition became much easier when I realized how similar Continental services and business traveler benefits were to the original Southwest Airlines business traveler, many years ago. While I hope the new business traveler program is successful, I would like to remind Southwest management that you can't have it both ways, your primary focus has to be on one segment or the other. In my opinion, current Southwest management has already succeeded in turning off a significant portion of business travelers over the last several years, I can only surmise that they'll now offend their primary leisure travelers, in their effort to regain lost business travelers. I wish Southwest success in this new program, but once again I see current Southwest Management playing with fire, convinced that they're going to satisfy everyone. As in most of their decisions over the last few years, they are simply pushing more and more of their better customers into the arms of their competitors. What made Southwest successful to begin with is the fact that they were different than the other carriers. Current Managment seems determined to become more and more like every other carrier. At the end of the day, I strongly believe that the current path, will end up being the demise of Southwest.

I finally got my parents to fly on Southwest - confirmed United, Continental and Delta diehard clients - so they could see why I talk SWA up all the time. Now you have this elitist system that will make it more difficult for my Dad, who is 6'5", to be assured of an aisle seat. I am not pleased with the new arrangement and would like to see my old friend, Southwest Airlines, back to the way things were. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. The early bird catches the worm and that's the way it should stay for those that check in early. With computer access and PDA's everywhere, it is not difficult to check in 24 hours in advance.

After using the new boarding method in Lubbock, I must say that it is a great improvement to everyone waiting in line for an hour before the flight. The problem in Lubbock is the very cheap signage in the line-up area, rather than the screens and columns that I saw getting off in Houston. I would hope that every station will eventually get the better set-up, because the numbers are so high on the signs in Lubbock, not to mention the fact that some of them were turned sideways, had everyone more confused. I applaud the new boarding, but please get us the good signage soon and get the cheap signs removed!

I love not standing in line for up to an hour anymore. However, with the new boarding system at the gates, all I can say is that your gate agents are the ones who can make it or break it but you know that already. You seriously need to weed out the brain dead and/or lazy ones who will break it by not making it work like it should work.

We flew November 9th from FLL to BNA on the 0710 nonstop and the female agent at the ticket lift podium was just about worthless with her announcements, despite it being a new procedure only one day old. We had A's in the low 20's yet there were 7 people in the A-21 to A-25 group. One of your male agents was walking by the line and I asked him 'How can there be 7 people in a group designated for 5?' He showed no concern at all and only when pressed for an answer he came up with 'It's probably overflow from an adjacent group!' That was BS because both adjacent groups had 5 people in them. Why couldn't he at least ask the 7 people to show their boarding passes to see who didn't belong there?

On the return trip November 13, both BNA's and TPA's agents maintained excellent control of how people lined up at the number poles and everything went very well, unlike FLL. The TPA female agent pulled a lady with a high 20's number over when boarding the first couple groups of A's - she tried to pull a quickie and got caught. She had to wait until the line progressed to where she should have been and was then allowed to go down the jetbridge.

Fix your gate agent problem or your new boarding system will tick off a lot of customers who see anarchy in the boarding lines.

Hugh J.

Gary, I'm not sure if this belongs under this subject but it is related to a relatively recent change that you've made. I see in your Spirit Magazine that "digital cameras" are now no longer allowed use below 10,000 feet. I haven't flown in a year or so so this must be fairly recent. I understand why certain devices are banned, as they may interfere with aircraft electronics, but I have never heard of this before and none of the other major airlines ban their use in this way. I've never had a problem with keeping my camera handy on a Southwest flight - in fact its been quite a conversation piece with some of the Flight Attendants and Pilots as many of your employees are also aviation enthusiasts. I have taken quite a few fascinating pictures while flying and I always get positive comments from those pictures that I have posted online. In fact, some of my pictures have been used by your cargo department for their annual employee calendar in the past. The scenery when flying is truly beautiful.

Southwest has a lot of employees as well as customers who are aviation enthusiasts. I was very disappointed to hear the cameras need to be shut off. I hope that you can re-consider this or perhaps make it more specific (as "digital cameras" covers a wide range) because it doesn't seem to be a problem for other carriers or the FAA.

Hi, I fly from Providence to Phily several times a year, always on Southwest and I've gotta say that from a customer service perspective the new Boarding procedure is just not working.

The old system was quick and efficient.

I wonder how much market testing was done before the new boarding system was implemented. Did any one on the SW BOD really examine the old process to see if it really needed fixing?

Surely the Business Class service could have been implemented without disrupting the process for those of us in steerage.

Other than this, I think that SW is great - all of the customer service staff
at the airports and on the phone are great!

Thank you for listening !

Dave

I am so sad as I write this. For 10 years I have never looked at another airline when traveling. I loved Southwest, I defended Southwest, I had all of my friends and family and extended family flying Southwest (and believe me with 9 siblings and families that is a lot of people). The problem is I have free flights from Rapid Rewards that I can not use when I need them. My husband is out of the country and all I wanted was my daughter to be able to come home to Kansas from California for Christmas. She only gets off work from Sunday through Tues. By the way she also has a free flight. When I look at booking I am told "not available" - well the flight is available is you have switched to the new business class rewards but that is not fair to those of us who have earned the standard award. I realize that you have a business to run and that times are hard. But Mr. Keller you always said that you put the regular people your customers first, I believe that this is not longer so. Seems like greed has overcome Southwest. There are seats available on these flights - this is a family time of year - what business is being conducted on the Sunday, Monday and Tuesday of Christmas week - open these flights to your regular everyday people. Don't be a Scrooge. I am sorry that I am being so mean in this e-mail, I am just so sad right now.

I just flew this week for the first time since the boarding changes. All I can say is THANK YOU. I love flying with Southwest. The crew has always been cheerful and helping.
The pre-boarding process used to always anger me. I'd check in 24 hrs before to get a good seat,but you know what - so can people with children. They didn't because they could get the best seat and not have to actually put forth any effort.
I have children and have flown with them. I didn't pre-board cause I didn't think it was necessary. I am SO glad you've changed that. We were boarded early and out of the gates on time.
Again I want to thank you for making the changes. I will never go anywhere else for my flying needs. You've rewarded the people who make the effort to get a good seat and it works! Kudos!!!
Thanks

I(we)have been flying with Southwest for some time now. Many of the trips are to/from St. Louis. Prior to the "change" I thought the boarding areas, were not very well situated for waiting passengersconsequently resulting in some raised tension(s) amongst some passengers. On 11/10/07 I again had a flight from St. Louis. The day previously, I got my boarding pass(A23), and arrived thinking everything would be running smoothly. In the boarding area, I observed the separated(1-5/6-10/11-15/etc.)areas. Passengers were loosely hanging around. After the "pre-boards", the male Southwest employee made one exclamation(I'll take 1 through 30)which then caused a minor somewhat uncontrolled rush to biard. This may be an improvement over the previous procedure, but not really that much. If this is how it is to be done, then there is no need for the separated sections(1-5, etc.). Thanks.......Bob Horvatich

I'm an American living overseas, so I've just now had the unpleasant surprise of discovering how Southwest's new "by the number" boarding system has coupled with your online checkin to sire a monster. Check in five minutes after 24 hours in advance = number 54. Check in two minutes after the starting gun = 32. So what this means is that I have to build my life around being near a computer to log on at exactly the right tiime, or accept a life consigned to C-ville.

I don't even know about the "business class" priority stuff, and I don't really care. Southwest has always been about great value for money, so why would I choose to pay more for your services? But what I do know is that the boarding changes have turned Southwest's weakest feature (no assigned seat) from an inconvenience into a nightmare.

For decades I have been a great booster of Southwest, using it as an example of how a business should be run - airline or other. You have been my domestic airline of choice on my frequent trips back to the States. But while I still appreciate your many strengths, I think this boarding mess has pushed me over the edge and back into the pool of your competitors. Of course I won't boycott Southwest, but I will never again do what I did this Thanksgiving weekend - choose Southwest over other more convenient and even cheaper alternatives because I expected you to treat me right.

Color me very disappointed.

I have been meaning to write to Southwest Air for many months. Your recent changes have prompted me to take the time to finally write. Before I start, please note that I have flown a Southwest round trip flight almost every week for the past 2 years. I am approaching approximately 100 round trip flights in 2 years; 95%+ on Southwest. I really feel like you all are part of my family. I mainly fly for business but several flights a year are pleasure as well. My wife and 2 sons, travel on Southwest as well.

First off, CONGRATULATIONS on the changes to the boarding process. Thursday November 8th was my first chance to experience the new process at PBI. I have flown about 6 flights under the new procedures. These changes have been a long time coming. For 2 years, I have been defending my turf in the A line, observing shouting matches, shoving matches, fights, ignorance, rudeness, etc. Thank God for this boarding process change. It worked very well on Thursday. I now have time to relax after the fun security process and before boarding. However I do agree that your boarding agents need to provide much better direction on the boarding process. Saying "A 1 through 30 can now board" causes much confusion, anger and angst. I suggest that they call out for A 1-5, then A1-10, A1-15, A1-20, etc. I have unfortunately already seen many fliers try to cut in front of others. e.g. those with A30 or higher going to the front of the line and not being stopped/questioned by your agents.

I think that your new boarding process has been well thought out including the family boarding. The prior system has been abused for way too long. And may I say "shame on you" to the many pre-boarders that blatently abuse the pre-board/wheelchair process. I have been shoved out of the way many times exiting the plane by those (now quite mobile walkers/runners) that came on via wheelchair. Miracles in flight, yes there are......every flight?!?

I am very pleased to hear about the new Boarding Pass priority A selection process as well. I guess this is as close as we will get (on Southwest) to priority boarding for frequent fliers like me. Thank you!! It would be great if we Priority fliers could get the boarding pass greater than 24 hours but I understand if you can't make that happen.

I am very close on the Companion Fare opportunity as well. I am somewhere in the 90 to 95 flight range. Guess I need to get a SW VISA to get a few extra credits.

May I thank you for your on-time, non-stop or direct flights, and affordable fares. Your flight attendants, pilots and gate attendants are very professional and helpful. I even appreciate their humor.
Now if you could only invent Southwest airplane toilet seats that stay up while "us guys" are going to the bathroomÃ

As a SWA 4x/year traveling family from ALB/MHT/BDL to MCO, we have MANY times witnessed the "miracle healing" on board. Simply amazing. Funny to see others commenting on the same.

We flew last in Oct., before the big changeover, but there was the family preboard, post A. Our son is six, so we've graduated from that procedure. Families seemed surprised to not be boarding first.

All three of us have RR cards - and we have always bought our son a seat - since his first flight at 6 mos.. We all have had several reward tickets in recent years. A SWA VISA is in our wallets too.

The biggest shock for me with the new system is the fare structure. Yikes! I understand that fuel costs have gone up, but the SWA fabulous fare structure is gone. I'm going to spend the least amount possible (for pleasure or business), so I guess we're now out of the A boarding.

I didn't mind rushing to get the 24 hr. in advance "to the second" boarding pass printed for A group and then parking myself at the gate to get the best choice of seat selection - except on those mega-preboard FL flights!

Not sure what the future holds for us and our preferred carrier. We LUV ya, but.......

I have flown SWA since the new boarding procedure, and it worked fairly well. However, the poles with the groups of 5 on them seem to be too close, as all 5 of us could not fit between them. Maybe there were people not lining in the right sport and this was the problem? Like others have said, enforcement will be the key, ensuring people board in their "group of 5" and not out of turn. My flight was half full, so that definitely helped make the process smooth. The only other thing is that there seems to be less seats in the waiting area to make room for the poles, thus not everyone will be able to sit until boarding as the new system is supposed to allow.

I found your website and decided to add my comments to them. I also fly many round trips on Southwest every year (my daughter lives in Southern California and we travel back and forth, some of the time she travels with her two little boys ages 2 and one half and two months. Her husband travels alot so she comes into Chicago.. She has traveled other airlines and really preferred your old pre-boarding system. However, now since there are not assigned seats, she has really been stressed out over the porcess of trying to gate check a double stroller and get the older two year old settled with his car seat, since she is now paying for his seat which is fine. There will be no way she will be able to handle these trips alone and more than likely I will be traveling back and forth just to help her. I read some of the comments from other travelers about some people who abuse the old pre-board system with older children, but really I have traveled alone and as an adult , can't some of those people give these young families a break and let them sit together and get settled, so they don't have other people behind them up their back. Also just today I was unable to board her with the internet, but her husband got an A pass #22 and her two year old son got an A pass #42, Absolutely insane. It would not let me pull up a boarding pass for her since she was told to put she would have a carry on two month old child, so it kicked her automatically to between the A and B passengers. In all the years I have travelled I rarely saw families abuse the pre-boarding status which made Southwest so popular with young families. I just wish those people who have written in complaining about family travel had to deal with the stress themselves.

Southwest is catoring to the business class of flyers and I will have to agree with a previous blogger that Mr. Kelly's video was very political.

It seems to me that Southwest has now created a "first class" for their airline and that is Business Plus. Those of us who fly for work or for pleasure are forced to pay the "first class" fare or risk getting a B or C unless we meet their number of flights rule. I like the boarding changes but I think Southwest pushed it a little too far. Keep the boarding changes but change the special treatment Business Plus people get and/or the REALLY frequent travelers receive. If we are sitting at our computer and push check in 24 hours in advance Southwest should be fair and allow us to get the number we deserve.

I have been flying Southwest for work while my fellow employees have been flying another airline because I liked Southwest. I will have to say, I will now be flying the other airline with my co-workers because sitting in a middle seat from Baltimore to San Diego is not worth it - especially if I check in at exactly 24 hours in advance.

I just checked in for my flight from Baltimore to San Diego - paid refundable fare price - and got an A30. I don't like it and this will be my last roundtrip on Southwest.

I am very disappointed with Southwest. Southwest allowed the average person to fly with no consequence of how much you paid, how often you flew and whether you were flying for work or pleasure. The average person, flying for pleasure, paying a fare they can afford can now enjoy a boarding group of C and a center seat.

Of course all the bloggers who fly for business like the new set up - they meet the flight criteria and they get the A-list treatment or they get their "A" boarding group reserved because they pay Business Plus fares. Southwest is now a business friendly airline and they seem to careless about the average flyer.

Lessoned learned: If you want a good seat, a low number in the A boarding group, you must now pay the Business Plus fare.

Just raise the fares across the board and make it fair for all.

I am quite surprised by the comments here. As a very frequent flyer for the last seventeen years, I have only flown Southwest on certain routes. Why? Because other airlines reward my repeated business with the ability to book the exit row aisle at ticketing.

I believe that these changes will get Southwest more of my business. My biggest concern in the past has been getting a decent seat on my return flight home. This is often at a time when I am not near a computer, but would be flying back on an unrestricted ticket. Southwest has lost a LOT of my business on 200-700 mile nonstop flights due to this approach. You've already picked up one trip in December where I would have normally flown American, because I could lock in my outbound on a Ding! fare and buy Business Select on the return (which is likely to not be known until 3-4 days in advance).

The resulting fare is lower than what will be available on American by the time the trip is completely locked in. I get 17D on the return, Southwest gets more revenue, and there are still a whole bunch of seats up front for families and other leisure fliers. I guess I don't see what the big problem is going to be? The reality is that if you're boarding pass is B10 or better, you're going to get a non-middle seat. For leisure travelers, if you care that much, be at the computer in advance.

One thing I HAVE noticed so far, however, is that you need more signage at the gate. Specifically, a sign that says in big easy to understand wording which groups should stay seated and which groups should be standing. At both MDW and BNA, it's not been clear to a lot of people what is going on, and a lot of B customers were trying to stand in the A1-30 line at the wrong time.

Gosh! I have a real easy comment.

ENFORCE YOUR OWN POLICY!

I really don't care how or why you change any aspect of your policy. You make those decisions based on research that I'm not aware of. Besides, once I learn any system I will be aware of what I need to do to get what I want out of it.

However, if you don't enforce your own boarding policies, then why even bother asking our opinions.

I have no desire to pay extra for Business Select when the A1 thru A15 area is crowded with A50's.

I'm an A-Lister and will be one for many more years but lining up as an A16 just allows the A50's to jump in front of me by breaking the rules.

So, even though I don't care how you change the policies I hate the new system because it is not enforced.

Love your airline but implementation of your new boarding is rocky. At MSY-NOLA , despite the Bingo seating on our boarding passes, the gate agents largely ignored it and it was the usual A,B,C which MOST of us mastered in kindergarten. Returning out of TPA, the gate agent tried to rigorously enforce it and had his intelligence and paternity questioned. There was no clear delineation of subgroups ie. groups of 5. The gate agents kept spinning the signage and sending people to the back of the line for being hapless. You're going to hemorrhage customers. The business upgrade is not an issue. Liberte,Egalite is a French thing. CB

To everyone who is SOOOOO happy that families with small children do not get to board 1st, I will be looking to sit right next to you with my 1 1/2 year old and I will not have a problem inconviencing you while I put everything away. Also, sorry if he talks to you or makes a noise, he does not understand the difference between the Business Select Passenger and the rest of the passengers. At his age he sees everyone the same not separate classes!!!

Something else that needs to be corrected and keeps coming up from the Business people who are spending someone elses money. IF YOU HAVE A LAP CHILD, SOUTHWEST AIRLINES WILL NOT LET YOU CHECK IN ONLINE, SO YOU DO NOT EVEN HAVE A CHANCE TO GET AN A.

Also, if there is 137 seats on a plane how can there be 60A's??????

I am not a business flier but I was the Loyal SWA customer who went to SWA for all of my flights. Maybe I am wrong but from what I see above I am not alone when I ask the question, Why change one of the only successful airlines in the US?? You company was built by people like me who loyaly flew 4-6 round trips a year. The last time I looked it was very successful, it will be interesting to see where you and your business travelers go when you stop seeing the families travel on SWA.

I wish you the best, I really like what you use to be.

Being a Southwest Operations Agent, Please Hear Me Out! Change is inevitable, but listen to this reasoning first-then fly us once before making a judgement!
We fly only Boeing 737 aircraft. We seat 137 passengers, with 6 seats across ( 3 on each side) and approximately 22-24 rows. For the comparison, I will use the least amount available to make this point.
With 22 rows per aircraft, that means that 44 aisle seats and 44 window seats ( two of each in each row) are available on each flight. That's a minimum of 88 "treasured" seats. This leaves approximately 49 middle seats per aircraft. This doesn't sound good to you if you are at the end of the B line or in the C boarding group. I counter complaints by telling passengers that "at least now you get to choose who you sit by and by not who sits next to you".-Other airlines don't give you this option!
As far as family boarding goes, please don't sell SWA short! Families already in possession of an A Boarding pass may board with the first group, ensuring seats together. Once the A group has boarded-possibly 60 people but most likely a lot less, we call for family boarding-parents traveling with children 4 yrs. or younger to board who are in the B and C boarding group which ensures seats together. Does this mean that if your child is 6 years old that you should be worried about them sitting next to a total and complete stranger? NO WAY!!!!! We will do everything to ensure you get to sit next to your small child. It may not be we can accomodate both parents in the same row, but there's too much liability to force a family with a small child who may need extra attention during the flight to split apart from both parents! Nobody wants to babysit anothers' child during a flight, so we will make sure that doesn't happen! Just try asking for someone onboard to give up their seat to accomodate a mother and small child and see if offers are taken. If that doesn't happen, then I just simply make an announcement that "we are now looking for a babysitter for the flight", and hands start to shoot up to volunteer!
I, personally don't agree with the Business Select seats, but I will try to explain it the best I can. I agree with trying to increase our revenue to off-set fuel prices, but I hate the fact that other people are now viewed as "more" important than others. With this said:
There are 15 seats (Boarding passes A1-A15) reserved for each flight for passengers wanting to board first, notice I say First, not Business. These fares are available to everyone, just with a $10-$30 tacked on due to fuel soaring fuel costs. In the first 2 1/2 weeks of our new boarding, I have had some flights with No Business Select passengers, and have just had my first flight today with my personal all-time high record of 4 Business Select passengers. Going with my "minimum" standard that I stated earlier, this means that with no Business Select passengers checked in the for the flight, that the person holding Boarding Pass A16 will be the first to board after our Pre-board passengers. To explain it in more detail for our passenger who is holding a B-1 Boarding pass: if only 3 people preboard and there are no Business Select passengers checked in, then they would be the 49th person to board the aircraft---leaving A LOT OF CHOICES ON SEATS. Yet, in the worst case scenario, let's say there are 10 preboarding passengers and 15 Business Select Passengers checked in, as well as the other 45 people who would be in the A group (60 total): There would be 70 seats already occupied, but still leaving 18 window or aisle seats and 49 middle seats (on a full flight) to choose from.
It's not as bad of an experience from the customer comments that I have received, but most people conjure up an opinion before trying it!
Ya, most companies have a "BAD APPLE" among them that can cost them a customer, but I FIRMLY BELIEVE THAT WE HAVE THE BEST EMPLOYEES OF ANY AIRLINE WHO ARE WILLING TO GO ABOVE THE "LEGACY STANDARD" to show how much we really do love Southwest Airlines!--Even in the amidst of change.
Has Southwest ever laid off an employee since 9/11 or filed or bankruptcy---NO!
And although no company is perfect, "most" of us will pass along our gratitude to YOU!

I bet I can make you smile!

I've got to say I'm a bit dissapointed. I've been a loyal Southwest customer for years, flying several times a year. I've enjoyed the fact that everyone is treated the same. You show up. You get on the plane. And you might sit next to a business person. You might sit next to a family on vacation. You might sit next to a kid going home from college. It was alwasy different, and you never knew who you were going to meet. Anyway, it set you apart. It was fun.

Now you're starting Business Select and the Business rates where certain people if they're willing to pay a little more are guaranteed to get on the plane a little bit earlier than everyone else and get the seat they want. Sounds like you're going the way of everyone else. Why not just have a business class section of the plane and while you're at it just assign everyone a seat. That's what the other guys would do.

Best of luck with you're new way of doing things.

A dissapointed fan who will probably fly you a little bit less because the differences are getting less and less.

Kory Tedrick
St. Louis, MO

This past week I made my first flight since you have changed your boarding procedure. I have ALWAYS LOVED flying Southwest and comparable to other airlines, have felt you ranked the highest in meeting family needs. I have always preboarded the plane with my infant, allowing for an easy in, easy out. Being in the front of the plane, also gave me quick access to the restroom for diaper changes and the flight attendents were always so helpful in helping to warm bottles. While I applaude your new boarding procedures numbering the A, B, and C lines, I found that your new boarding of families between A and B makes things much more difficult. Have you ever attempted to board with a stroller, baby carrier, diaper bag, and infant? Now I not only have all of these items, but must avoid hitting all of the A boarders along the process. I think you should reconcider your new policy and instead place emphasis on the families you are allowing to preboard. As has been stated in earlier comments, many of these families have children well over the preboard age. I will continue to fly Southwest for individual travel but will consider other options when flying with my children.

Since 9/11, any smart traveler will arrive at the airport 2 hours early. Now instead of sitting on the floor enjoying the company of our fellow travelers, we must mill around the greedy food vendors. I have been a loyal SWA traveler for many years and have had a companion pass for the pass 4 years. But alas, since I have not traveled as much this year, I do not qualify for preferred boarding. You have made a joke out of Rapid Rewards, since you have started restricting the available seats. I guess the new fee structure will replace what you lose from the fleeing client base that made you successful. You have moved from something special to just another airline. Maybe one of your competitors will adopt your business plan that has made you and capture your former customers as they flee. I always felt special on SWA and I m sad to see so many good memories fade!

Just flew for the 2nd round trip time in a month, this time with my family of 5. We checked in on-line within minutes of the 24 hr starting time and got A56. Since we needed seats together we ended up in the 20th row. People flying solo took up the rows in the front of the plane, it was horrible. This process is just ridiculous!!!!

What about the people that do not have a computer? My older family members do not (they are in there 70's) So now what, it becomes my problem to check them in online or else they will be group "c", unless they pay an extra $200 for the flight? That's a bunch of BS! Just give us a seat number when we book our flight!

You have no idea what it is like to travel with children. Shame on you Southwest!

If the primary goal of Southwest's boarding procedure is to board the plane faster (I think both the old and new system share this goal), there needs to be a way to align the goals of passengers and the airline together. There really isn't a lot of motivation now for passengers to board quickly.

Perhaps a way to 'reward' passengers for boarding the plane quickly could be implemented. For example, let's say SWA expects to board a plane in 15 minutes (this would vary based on the number of ticketed passengers). Perhaps a reward system where the passengers receive something if they board faster (maybe a .25 RR credit bonus, free drink coupon, or a $5 credit on their account). I think the prospect of a reward for boarding the plane more quickly may motivate passengers to load their bags quicker, clear the aisle faster, etc.

The only negative I can think of is passengers getting mad at another passenger for taking too long to clear the aisle, but I think if the reward is small enough, people will be motivated without being too upset when they don't get it.

Thoughts?

As a long-legged frequent flyer who hasn't flown another than SWA in a few years but whose 24-hour in advance check-in nets only #A22 and whose flights may decrease in the future due to a work change, I say "farewell to my favorite exit-row seats with leg room...I have enjoyed and will miss ye. I hope the business elite whose bottom will rest there, is as in-shape as I am to preserve your springs, and that they will enjoy it as much as I have!" I'll still fly SW but my allegiance is likely swayed.

I've always enjoyed flying Southwest, but did not look forward to the check-in. People playing cards in the floor, waiting an hour or more in advance, luggage holding places in line, it all seemed a little ridiculous to me.

I think the new changes have reduced the stress of the check-in, and I thought it was well organized. Oh, and I love business select. When I am traveling on business and have to book flights last minute, I'll pay the extra. And I like moving of the boarding of children to between A & B.

The mark of a good airline: alway striving to be the best including trying different things to make things better. Great Job!

I don't know why all these people are such whiners!! If you check in online as a family, don't you get all your boarding passes together?? You can still sit together, you just don't get to use your kids to get you ahead, allowing us singles relief from your choice to have kids, I mean, please, a family of five getting to board first because ONE of them is under five years old?? Please tell me your kids serve a higher purpose than to get you a better seat on a plane-isn't sitting together as a "family" good enough? For those that "liked" to sit on the dirty, disgusting floor with strangers who could care less about you as a "fellow passenger", you don't HAVE to sit on the floor-you can relax in one of the many restaurants, bookstores, or lounges!! Whomever would CHOOSE to sit on the floor as opposed to any one of the other options shouldn't be paid much attention to anyway-neither should anyone who can't spell/write better than their five-year-old!! As for those that don't have computers, GET WITH THE TIMES!! THANK YOU SWA!!! It is GREAT that you recognize the importance of time in all of our busy lives, now we can truly spend more time doing what we CHOOSE, instead of being FORCED to wait in line to board two or more hours before a flight just because of these vultures!!

I love SWA. I love the new boarding procedure. And I love the fact that Southwest continues to innovate and arrive at a completely different solution to the boarding issue while not sacrificing the open seating that we've come to love.

Keep doing it right and keep making money. I love flying a profitable airline!

Does it really what age your child is JMH? I have 3 children ranging in age from 8 to 5. Last month my 8 year old had to sit a few rows behind me with strangers. That is a very scary thing for a child of any age. The point is that parents should not be forced to be separated from there children because of others insensativity!

I have flown SWA several times since the new boarding was implemented. I love it. No more watching people act like cattle standing in line for hours when the plane has not even arrived. I have not had a problem getting an A thus far except once and I still got an aisle seat even with that B. Keep up the good work SWA. Looking forward to my next flight in a couple of weeks.
I don't know what people are complaining about with this new system. It works for me.

My round trip flights to Tuscon and back on Thanksgiving were the first I have taken on Southwest and I was delighted with your on time departures and arrivals, good ticket pricing, people friendly savvy and professionalism throughout. From start to finish it was a pleasure to fly on Southwest and I will certainly check you out first next time. Thanks!

Heads up to those that are flying either MCI-DAL or DAL-SAT this week. There will be a even greater need to check in as close to 24 hours before as possible due to the Missouri football fans going to San Antonio. Also since Kansas and Missouri have the same home airport (MCI), there is a possiblity that these flights have been/will be overbooked because of the Kansas cancellation possibilities. Make sure you check-in early to get your seats. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Please, please, please bring back pre-boarding for families with infants and toddlers....it is difficult enough flying with little ones as it is, and this is one thing that just seemed to make things easier. Waiting in line with a toddler while the people behind you get annoyed that it's taking so long (to fold up your stroller, get the car seat installed, etc.) is just no fun for anyone. I know a lot of people have issues with children flying, but the reality is that families are spread out these days and 12+ hours in a car seat in the car is just not feasible. On another note, is there any possibility to retrofit the cabin bathroom with a baby changing table? It seems like most of the major airlines have them these days with the exception of Southwest. This is just a small customer amenity that would really have a big impact on a family's flying experience. We've had such great customer service experiences on Southwest, but feel like they're just not very "family-friendly" when it comes to flying with infants and toddlers these days.

How about, Families will be able to board first, if they would like sit in the last 10 rows. They would then be close to the rear galley and bathroom. Boarding first,it gives them time to get situated as the front of the plane starts to fill. (without clogging the isle). At the destination, ground crews have time to have strollers and car seats on the jet way when the get off last.

WSJ article today, Nov 27, about SWA's shift to business instead of leisure travelers.

Jennifer, Parents traveling with small children deserve and need extra assistance! Many of us have been there (as passengers traveling with children) and we remember how tough it was. I remember the days of trying to fold up the stroller with a diaper bag over one shoulder, totebag and baby in the other...wondering if I had too many carry-ons!

Changing tables in the restrooms are about to become a reality.
I'm not sure of the date but they should be rolling out soon if not already. Hooray!

We do like to think we are a family-friendly airline and we love seeing travel made a little easier for all of our families. Always know the flight attendants are most happy to help you. Many of us are mothers too! Families are LUVed at SWA!

The new boarding process is ridiculous. You took something that was already horrible and made it worse.

1. The signs are not clear
2. Apparantly in the A1-30 line we are all supposed to order ourselves? You've got to be kidding me. So we should be checking with each other to see what number we are? Could you make it more difficult? Your gate agent denied me because I was A29, he said I should be at the end of the A1-30 line, and then he let on someone with a A20 boarding pass. So he was obviously just being a jerk. Thanks.
3. Why not just go back to the numbers - no numbers and letters - and call 1-20, 11-20, 21-30, etc. That seemed to work fine for years and years.

I refuse to fly your airline again. I would rather take Amtrak AND pay more! My last business trip to Reno was pure torture - no matter how cheap, it's no bargain.

I am a businessman and travel frequently. I recently used Southwest to fly to Phoenix. My experience with the boarding process was not a good one. The efficiencies gained by Southwest may be great but the inefficienties of the process on customers is also great. To start with, to get a "choice" you have to go to the Southwest website and click on the button 24 hours ahead to get a good "choice" seat. If you don't click within a millisecond of the time, your chance of getting a good seat is not happening. In addition, I had to leave a meeting to go a web computer to perform this function both on the trip out and back. Talk about unintended consequences. I also do not like standing like cattle in the lines prior to boarding. I don't have to do this on other airlines. I don't feel the anxiety of not knowing. This may be fantastic for Southwest but the mumbling in the cattle lines is not positive. I don't have the time or the will to go through this process just for a flight again. Sorry.

My wife and I fly Southwest every about every three weeks and have loved your airline and have converted several friends from Jetblue to SW. Now we absolutetly despise your new boarding system. We liked sitting in the only 2 seater by the exit door and not having anyone sit next to us. For about 28 consecutive flights we were able to obtain these seats because, under the old system and the precise moment we were able to obtain our online pass, I usually got between 1 and 15, not that at this point it mattered because we got to the airport early and were willing to stand in line so we could get those seats. NOW...the precise moment we are able to get those online tickets, the best we can do is 37 and 48. And during our last couple of flights, guess what? Those two seaters were gone. To make matters worse, on both occasions after we got our seats, young kids ended up in back of us, only to kick our backs the entire trip from Orlando to Manchester, despite asking them to stop. Under the old way, preboarding the kids, we could be sure we were not next to screaming, crying and kicking kids. Several other flyers in line also said they prefered the old method as well. We did notice it was also a lot more effort for your employees trying to get everyone in place.

You should also try and change you online pass system to obtain two separate confirmation numbers at the same time. Duing the past trip we used two separate RR tickets. And while I was in the 30's my wife 's number was in the 40's.

I cannot believe we are actually considering flying another line once we use up our combined 8 RR tickets plus flights we have already paid for.

Arthur, Wells, Maine

Andrea, thanks for the great news that Southwest's Ops Agents are enforcing the sequence. The poles with the numbers mark your correct position, so you don't need to ask others what numbers they have in order to find your correct place. If after knowing that you still prefer to try boarding out of sequence then you really do belong on another airline.

What many people here don't yet realize is that slots A1-A15 are normally almost empty. Those are the Business Select slots that mostly go unsold. So the A20 you saw was actually in the first 5 mini-group of non-Business Select passengers. The Ops Agent did it exactly right.

It's a good system. Learn it and you'll love it.

One recommendation to Southwest from this customer: Go ahead and ratchet down the count of Business Select slots sooner rather than later. You can let it grow later. The reason is to eliminate the large gap (nearly empty A1-A15 positions) that confuses newbies and tempts line jumpers. Operational considerations outweigh potential but unlikely revenue, at least for now.

David.....What an excellant idea "pre-board families in the last 10 rows". I have children and that works for me, and does cut down on the boarding process. They should from back to front anyway, just makes sense doesn't it. As a parent, my main concern is that I sit with my children, not that I get the front seat. David, you deserve a job on the SWA planning board!

Can some one put on the main website the deal with the A1-A15 Business Select spots and also A-1 treatment exist only 36 hours and up for the A-1 people. Thanks.

The new boarding system is stupid and more trouble than it's worth. Leaving Salt Lake City, the gate worker didn't even bother to check that people were in the right number order, so I ended up at the end of the line when I shouldn't have been. Returning from St. Louis at least the numbers were respected, but then I had to ask myself -- what exactly is the point of this? What makes this better than the old way? Answer: NOTHING; it's not better. In fact, it's worse! If there are no official assigned seats, you're still lining up to choose whatever is available. You still get an A, B, or C boarding group, so you're still going to be further ahead or further behind in line to choose based on that. The only difference is that if I arrive at the airport in time to queue up in the B line, and be the 4th person, under the old system, I was rewarded for being on-time or early. With this new system I can get there an hour early and it won't matter because as a B60, someone who just barely makes it before boarding with an B7 gets to board way ahead of me. The genius behind SWA was it's "first-come-first-served" process, and the cheaper prices that came with that. But with your fare increases and your crazy boarding rules I may as well fly another carrier where I can go online and choose the seat I want, show up whenever I want, and not have to get in a line with my number like a 4th grader. SWA needs to seriously rethink these changes; you're destined to lose a LOT of customers. Have you forgotten that what made SWA so great was how DIFFERENT you were from all of the other airlines?????

As a business traveler, often flying 3 or more times a week, I LUV the new boarding process. I am now able to arrive a little later and get more work done at the same time. The revamped gate areas are LUV-ly and so customer oriented!!! The A+Priority is awesome too. The only change I would make would be in the alcoholic beverage area...I have all these free drink tickets and you really don't serve alcohol that I drink. ....if you only served White Zinfindal, Amaretto or Michelobe Ultra ! SW still has the best flight attendents and flight crews around!!!!!! Thanks for all you do.

I am very disappointed in the new Southwest boarding procedure. I think the concept in theory is an improvement but in reality it seems to show favortism to select groups of people and disorganization to a system that used to work well.
My family has been flying across country using Southwest exclusively for several years now, I flew under the new system yesterday and was very discouraged with Southwest. The B and C rows were boarding and there never were annoucements made for the A boarding. The gate personnel were changing the A: sign to the B: sign before announcing the A: boarding, causing confusion. The pushy customers were even more pushy than before and were just allowed to do what they wanted. It really appeared to be a deterioration from the previous method.
Go back to the old ways, that was what made your airlines the BEST in the business and my family's exclusive airlines by offering reasonable rates and the freedom to select your seating neighbors upon seeing the circumstances at hand.
I am all for trying to attract more business travelers but please do not forget about the recreational travelers that have made your airlines what it is today.

I am writing this message with the hope it actually reaches someone in the Southwest decision making process who will read it. I am sure there are good reasons for many of the changes Southwest has made recently. Some I agree with, some I donÃ

SWA Gate Agents need to announce and enforce the numerical order of the Boarding Passes. You've added these numbers, now use them. Just this week I purchased and flew with a Business Select ticket. At boarding time a passenger with A 27 walked on ahead of me. I paid twice as much as her and she got the same benefit. On the return flight the Agent announced "A 1 through 30" and everyone just scrambled regardless of their number.

Here's what I learned: why bother paying $367 when I can get at the head of the line even with a $109 ticket.

Here's a simple suggestion: when the Agent announces it's boarding time he/she should be scripted to instruct the passengers to line up in numerical order according to their Boarding Pass. The Agent will need to say this over a few times to reinforce it. Then the Agent should call up the groups seperately, as in 1-5, 5-10, 10-15, 15-20, and so on. Secondly, the Agent should make any "high numbered" passengers who attempt to board in the first groupings step aside and wait until their group is called. Do this a few times and others will get the idea.

Your promos for the new boarding procedure talk about spending less time waiting in line. Well the opposite is happening: people are camping out early in line to get a better boarding position in their Letter group, just like the old days.

In sum, the number system . . . use it or lose it!

I've posted a few times before on this topic. Quick synapse: LUVin' it.

BUT, it just occurred to me after reading another post above that your new Business Select fare will be short-handed as "BS". I found this to be fairly amusing.

Personally, I feel as though your marketing people could have come up with a WILDLY more exciting name that is more fun than "Business" and "Business Select", which is so dry and boring and not the typical SWA style. I expected more creativity from the airline that turned a mini-skirt incident into a hilarious and successful national advertising campaign :)

Just some thoughts.

Regardless, see y'all at LAX in a couple weeks when I travel with friends to LAS for a fun filled day! Happy flying!
cheers, artie

We want to give the new procedures a chance like Gary, Brian and Kevin has asked us to do. Reading all the above sounds like many gate agents don't understand it and thus aggravating us customers. Upper management, I hope you are reading these comments and take appropriate steps to "retrain" some of the CSA's. Just like shopping at a new store or eating in a new restaurant, if you have a bad experience the first time, you really don't want to go back. This could happen to many of the SWA customers. I fly for the first time next week from MCO to BNA and back. I'm anxious to see how things are working.

I personally like the new boarding for families. There was nothing more annoying than arriving at the gate an hour and half early, being the first person in the A group line, then have 40 people walk up at the last minute to pre-board. I look at it as, if you need to pre-board, you need to follow the same rules as everyone else and get there early, not just skip up to the gate at the last minute and get on first.

As far as the new pricing......not really into it. We fly Southwest exclusively because they go everywhere we want, with the exception of COS and the prices are perfect. Now, if you want to get a decent seat, you have to pay a higher fare, not to mention fly 16 roundtrips in a year. I do fly alot, but not 16 times a year.
As the saying goes...if it ain't broke, don't fix it! Everyone was happy with the original pricing. The pre-board defineltly needed an overhaul, but the fares were wonderful....now, not so much.

Good luck with the new fare structure.

When I heard about the new seating procedure I silently cheered. Now I won't have to see the floor loungers (EWW--I'm a nurse and always skeeved by this behaviour) and the line from H-E-double hockey sticks full of preboard families and "disabled" people. Might even be able to enjoy my airport breakfast without the pressure of lining up for a seat. And perhaps the ex-floor loungers will join me.

I try to fly SWA whenever I can. They are usually on-time and my baggage is coming off of the belt before I get there. I like the new boarding method (people don't need to sit on the floor for an hour before the flight) --- except the change of pre-boarding families with infants or children under 3yrs. As an "A" boarder I want the choice of whether I sit next to a crying and screaming baby. They used to be in the front of the plane -- Now I hear them all over the plane and there is no way to get away from them. For those that have "Miracle Cures" while flying I think I may have the solution to the problem -- Seat anyone that is preboarded because of a disability in certain rows. Those rows will then have to wait until everyone has deplaned before they will be allowed to deplane just like real disabled persons. I have added the quote from a mother who is also unhappy with the small infant pre-boarding change, I thought it was right on from her perspective and from mine also -- "To everyone who is SOOOOO happy that families with small children do not get to board 1st, I will be looking to sit right next to you with my 1 1/2 year old and I will not have a problem inconviencing you while I put everything away. Also, sorry if he talks to you or makes a noise, he does not understand the difference between the Business Select Passenger and the rest of the passengers. At his age he sees everyone the same not separate classes!!! " I will continue to use SWA whenever possible and look forward to improvements in the tweaking process.
Thanks for listening, Don

I am starting a campaign to promote children and friends of Customers who need curb to gate and gate to curb wheelchair assist to please place your party in a chair, park your car, get a escort document and push you party. There are not enough wheelchair attendants to meet the demand during peak times and holidays. To abandon a wheelchair Customer in the elements and skip out is a sin on humanity, there ought to be a law. How we treat our parents is how our children will treat us.

I am a 25 year devoted SWA customer. One of the things I have always liked was ABC boarding scheme, which I thought was quite fair. If you had your STUFF together and checked in early...you are in the A group. If you didn't better luck next time. Plus I am friends with a few of your mechanics who explain taht you actuallt DO regular quality maintenace on the 737...

I tried your new business class (guaranteed A classification plus a beer...) on my last flight. It was a complete joke (excpet for the beer). On both ends from Houston to Midland the gate clerk hosed up the now complex A1-30 and A31-60...B1-30, etc signs so people could not figure out which lane to stand in. They had them turned the wrong way and I had to jump from the wrong line to the right one...at the last minute TWICE. At the end of a long day in the oilfield, it is often the only solace you get that you actually know how the bloody line works at the gate...as was echoed in many blogs above this a step backwards. The beer was good, but the new signs have got to go.:(

This has actually made me (gasp) consider trying Continental to MAF.

Please reconsider...

I just listened to Gary Kelly's comments about the changes...

I did not get the feeling he was actually listening to anyone but himself...having sat in MANY of these cheerleadning sessions.

Time will tell. I am very concerned about the future of the service I have grown accustomed to...it will not take much of a tweak to fix the ABC sign fiacso...let's all see how customer focused we REALLY are...

I know very well you can't be all things to all people...BUT there is great truth and wisdom in "don'i fix it if it a'int broke". Of course, I don't have to listend to all the comments or pay SWA's fuel bill...I'm just a humble oilfield engineer and possibly former customer.

I'll try SWA again in a week for my next trip to the field and see if things are improving...

I had my first expierence with the new boarding system over the Thanksgiving Day holiday. I have to say as a person who chooses to fly S.W. before the other airlines I didn't much care for the new system. My husband flies on your airline about once a week for business, so he atomatically was in the A group. A16 to be exact, but since I only fly when we vacation I was in the B group. Now we are adults and I realize he can just save me a seat, which he did, but what about families that fly with many people? Are we asking that they all stand in different locations??? There seems to be something not quite right about it. Maybe there needs to be a on online checking system that would allow a group of people traveling together to at least be able to board together??? Just a suggestion.

I also am not in favor of families boarding after the A group. My husband and I don't have children, but what I just experienced on our flight recently wasn't enjoyable. In the past families would board first and they did usually chose the seats up front. It aloud the rest of us to decide if we wanted to seat next to someone who would probably have a crying child. Instead, there was a dad, mom who was holding a baby, and a 3 year old behind us. The 3 year old kicked my seat the entire 2 hour flight because he can't reach the floor, and a baby who cried most of the way. Now I realize neither of these things were not being done to purposefully irrate but, with the old system I could have and would have choosen to sit a few rows away. Now families have to find spots where they can.

I do think some change is good, but it seems all that was good has gone and so many loyal customers are rethinking the airline they will fly. It seems you have forgotten why your loyal customers have always choosen to fly with S.W. and we are rethinking our choices. I know I am.

I am totally disappointed with your new flying practices. YOU ARE SELLING OUT---the one reason I respected and flew your airlines was because of the fair practices and lack of discrimination between the classes. That is the reason you grew to become the sucessful company that you did. Look at other companies who became too greedy--they went bellied up and you deserve the same thing if you carry forward with these changes.

Not allowing people with young children to board first is disgusting. I don't have young children but I feel for those who do. There is no excuse for this. WhaT are you going to do with people with other disabilities--make them wait too!!!

YOU NEED TO RETHINK THIS BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE. THE PEOPLE WHO MADE YOU GREAT ARE THE ONES YOU ARE NOW TURNING ON.

IT IS OBVIOUS TO ME THAT SW "AGENTS" ARE THE KEY TO MAKING THIS NEW SYSTEM WORK........GARY, BRIAN, CAN WE GRADE THEIR PERFORMANCES????????????????????????? MAYBE THEN THOSE WHO PAY MORE, WILL NOT HAVE ANYONE CUT IN LINE OF THEM...(BY THE WAY, THAT ISN'T ME, I'M A DING KIND OF PERSON) BUT I WOULD BE IRRATE IF WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO SOME OF THEM HAPPENED TO ME..

ALSO, JOAN WASKI, WHOM CALLED THAT LADY A "WITCH" FOR NOT CHANGING SEATS SO SHE COULD SEAT WITH BOTH HER KIDS....THAT "WITCH" AS YOU CALLED HER, HAS RIGHTS TOO....SHE PAID LIKE ANYONE ELSE TO GET THE SEAT SHE WANTED, AND BECAUSE YOU WERE SO OBLIVIOUS TO THE CHANGES THAT SW MADE (AND MAY I SAY, HAS ADVERTISED ETC FOR A WHILE) SHE SHOULD NOT BE PUNISHED FOR YOUR "LACK OF INFORMATION".......YOU SAY NOW YOU KNOW WHAT TO DO, BUT ON YOUR RETURN TRIP THERE IS NO INTERNET...HELLO, ARE YOU FLYING LIKE TO SPACE? OOPS, I'M SORRY, THEY HAVE COMMUNICATION LINES THERE ALSO.....WHY NOT HAVE SOMEONE FROM "THE EARTH" YOU LEFT OUT OF, CHECK YOU IN WHEN ITS TIME, AND ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS REPRINT YOUR BOARDING PASS........IT DOESN'T TAKE A ROCKET SCIENTIST TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO MEET YOUR BOARDING NEEDS.......BUT FOR YOU TO THINK THAT "EVERYONE" NEEDS TO BECKON TO YOUR NEEDS ON THE PLANE BECAUSE YOU HAVE KIDS IS OUTRAGEOUS...........WE HAVE KIDS ALSO, DON'T GET ME WRONG, AND IF WE WERE LATE IN BOARDING, THEN UNFORTUNATELY WE WILL HAVE TO REAP THE CONSEQUENCES......ANOTHER ALTERNATIVE, PAY THE HIGHER FARE TO BE ASSURED OF BOARDING FIRST, OR FLY ANOTHER AIRLINE.........

WE FLEW OVER THANKSGIVING AND OUR KIDS FLEW FROM RALEIGH, WHICH THEY SAID WAS VERY UNORGANIZED, BECAUSE THE GATE AGENT JUST SAID "THOSE IN A1-30) LINE UP......SO OF COURSE, YOU KNOW THE REST, EVERYONE JUST ON IN ANY POSITION AND WOULDN'T MOVE BECAUSE THE AGENT DIDN'T TAKE A FEW SECONDS TO TELL THEM HOW TO LINE UP, AND AS WE KNOW, NOT EVERYONE WILL TEND TO THE RULES............SO, LET US GIVE A GRADE ON THE AGENTS AFTER OUR BOARDING (CARDS TO CHECK WHATEVER) AND HAVE A SLOT AFTER GIVING OUR TICKETS TO THE AGENT TO DROP IT INTO TO.....THEN WE'LL SEE WHO DOES WHAT THEY ARE SUPPOSE TO...

WE FLEW FROM HOBBY AND IT WENT FINE, ALTHOUGH NOT 100%..OUR RETURN FROM VEGAS WAS VERY GOOD........THE AGENT EXPLAINED THE PROCEDURES SEVERAL TIMES, THEN WHEN IT WAS TIME TO REALLY BOARD, HE HAD THOSE FROM A31-60 BOARD AGAINST THE WINDOW, THE THOSE FROM A1-30 BOARD SECOND, THAT WAY NO ONE WOULD BE CROSSING EVERY WHICH WAY......WAY TO GOOOOOOOOO..IT WENT FLAWLESSLY.......

WHEN OUR CHILDREN BOARDED VEGAS TO RALEIGH, IT WASN'T QUITE 100%, BUT THEY SAID BETTER THEN IN RALEIGH, SO LAS VEGAS HAD THEIR DUCKS IN A ROW ON THESE FLIGHTS...........

FOR THOSE WHO LOVED THE OLD SYSTEM SAYING THEY DIDN'T MIND STANDING IN LINE FOR A COUPLE OF HOURS, ARE YOU KIDDING??????????????????????????????????????? THAT MEANS YOU HAVE TOOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH TIME ON YOUR HANDS, AS MANY OF US DO NOT, AND HATED THE CATTLE WAIT AND CALL......

THANK YOU SO MUCH SOUTHWEST FOR MAKING THESE CHANGES...ALL OF THEM.......OUR LITTLE ONES WHO TRAVEL WITH US HAVE ADJUSTED FINE, KNOWS NO DIFFERENT, YET WONDERS WHY OTHER MOMMIES ACT SO MEAN ON THE PLANE.......I TELL THEM TO JUST WATCH "HOW THEY SHOULD NOT ACT" AND JUST SMILE REGARDLESS.

WE LOVE THE "NON CATTLE CALL"............LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT.....NOW, TWEAK YOUR AGENTS INTO DOING THEIR JOB BY MAKING SURE EVERYONE IS IN THEIR PRESPECTIVE PLACES, WITH NO LINE CUTTING....MERRY CHRISTMAS.......(I'LL LET YOU KNOW HOW OUR FLIGHTS DURING NEW YEARS GO WHEN WE FLY YOU AGAIN...CAN'T WAIT!!! GEE, WE LOVE SOUTHWEST!!!!!!

Dear Mr. Kelly and Southwest Airlines,

As a loyal Southwest customer for many years, I can say with certainty that the appeal of flying Southwest has always been your unique approach to customer service. Everything from your boarding procedure to having flight attendants sing after the plane lands adds a bit of welcome personality to your airline that you can't find anywhere else.

As I fly regularly (although not enough to reach your new A-listers club), I have now had the experience of using your new boarding procedure several times. I fully expected that I would have some strong negative feelings towards the new procedure since I am one of those "crazies" who likes to line up at the front of the A line. However, I have found that I am rather indifferent towards the new procedure. Part of me is sad that I will never experience the fun of waiting for an hour and a half at the front of the A line, but part of me is pleased that I can do whatever I want right up until it is time to board.

It is slightly amusing to watch the different reactions of passengers at different cities. It seems to me that those passengers at larger hubs were more alert to the changes and more willing to follow the numerical order. At other, smaller airports however, people were simply confused and had difficulty following the new instructions. I overheard one gate agent telling a fellow passenger that the changes were, in part, Southwest's attempt to address complaints from passengers who were dissatisfied with having to wait in line for up to 2 hours to get their choice of seat on the plane. Well, it seems to me, and I say this with only the utmost respect to my fellow loyal Southwest customers, that by catering to the lazy, Southwest has managed to confuse the incompetent travelers - who usually are also the most lazy passengers. But, once again, I repeat that I am not against the new boarding procedures, I can follow simple directions, like how to line up in numerical order.

What I am strongly against, as echoed by some other commenters, is your new policy of allowing those who pay more for their flight to board within the first 15 of the A passengers. The best thing about Southwest in all of the years that I've flown is that you make no distinction between someone who paid full fare and someone who paid the lowest fare.

So, while I have no complaints with the new system (as yet, I haven't been lower than A45 and that was for a completely full flight) I do miss the "old days." Perhaps it's time to go back to the old method of handing out boarding cards one hour before each flight to those who planned well enough to be at the gate on time, because sometimes, simpler is better. But above all, I would hope that no matter what Southwest does with regard to their boarding policies that they remain the fun, friendly airline that I LUV to fly.

Sincerely,

Stephanie Plummer

I was on a six hour flight yesterday with two screaming, jumping, unruly children in front of me. I call the one who kept standing on her seat and leaning over to drop things on my lap 'rosemary's baby.' It was AWFUL, and the parents did nothing, despite repeated unbelievably polite requests by my husband and myself (such as, ' could you ask your daughter to sit down?' and 'might it be possible to take that stinky diaper to the rest room and get rid of it?'

It's not the kids fault, I understand, but SIX HOURS.
Not a child hater, no 'when my kids were little.....soapbox.

I have flown Southwest great deal -- I will fly Southwest more now!

I APPLAUD THIS STEP !
I

I'm not sure anybody cares @WN headquarters anymore about the boarding changes debate, but if you spend millions you better care. After 3 weeks of flights, the latest yesterday it requires a sound off. Both flights last week were a gaggle at the gate, Gate agents for SW are "spinless" and sleep in bathtubs due to their condition. On tuesday ABQ to PDX WN didn't have the poles up for the A, B,C boarding positions, it was line up any damn way you wanted. The return flight I had my usual A-16 (A-Lister) and My wife A-27 (Companion Pass), we had no BS fares in front of us and a A-31, A27, and A-32 ahead of me. I protested to GA and he said "I can't do everything" . The point is why bother, as I switch to Frontier and UA after years of flying WN maybe I just vote with my feet.

I am one of those "chosen few" who received the promise of a guaranteed A spot in your boarding process because of the amount of trips that I fly on Southwest. I average one to two round-trips per week on your airline; thus I assume that I am one of those "road warriors" to whom you are now attempting to pander with your new boarding system. That being said, I find your latest attempt at squeezing some more dollars out of your favored customers to be nothing short of reprehensible.
There are those business travellers who understand that their company is trying to save as much money on expenses as Southwest seems bent on extracting that money by creating classes of boarders, not passengers. To me, paying an artificially high fare which is passed on to our company under the guise of a business expense just for the privalige of boarding earlier is nothing short of asking business travellers to steal from their employer.
Other airlines of course have different classes of tickets, and with that purchase comes ceratin supposed amenities, be it larger seats, meal service, or just a certain distance from the obligatory screaming child that some people seem to feel empowered to share with their fellow passengers - for some people these amenities are worth the extra price. But Southwest offers no such amenities - one would have to go to only the most upscale hotel to be willing to pay $30 for a single drink as you now offer. And as I have experienced over the years, even early boarding does not guarantee a passenger any more privacy or comfort than any other patron who boards later...I can be the absolute first to board and still end up sitting next to a 300-pounder in a center seat who spends the trip spilling into my side - the only thing that I am guaranteed with an A or B boarding pass is overhead bin space.
So while I do applaud the changing of how families and other "assisted passengers" now load (as was pointed out in another posting, too many people abused this policy and putting them in-between the A & B groups still guarantees them the chance to sit together), and while I appreciate the promise of being guaranteed an "A" boarding pass (that is, unless you sell all of the A's to higher-paying customers), I refuse to play Southwest's new game of "pass the costs on to the boss" and will not be participating in your little experiment at revenue improvement.
I thank you for my 15+ years of weekly round trips, but after my current group of pre-paid reservations runs out, I will be giving my business and my company's weekly business to another airline where I can see an actual return on my flying dollar. Congratulations on doing more to prop up your competitors' bottom line than they could have ever done on their own.

Mr Kelly,

I watched your video and im glad your happy with your new changes. As CEO of my company I can not justify the cost. Last week I priced SWA from Louisville Ky to Lax. your cost was over $800 I flew Northwest with a seat asignment and early bording for $362. Plus on two of the flight we had a video monitor in each seat. free. I am on the "A" list but won't use it.

Rick

The new boarding process has been going pretty well until my last flight on Thursday Dec 6th. Don't get me wrong. I love the freedom that the new boarding process gives us. not defending my turf for 2 hours before the flight and being able to go to the bathroom & get a meal instead of sitting on the floor is priceless. i am not asking you to change anything just enforce the boarding order. at PBI on Thursday morning, i had (as I usually do) the coveted A16 slot. There were no BS A 1-15's. No less than 14 people somehow boarded in front of me!!!!! This is not right at all. Is this what i have earned? The 2 gate attendants not only totally ignored the boarding pass order/numbers, they were making fun of it. i strongly encourage you to enforce the order or there will be fights once again in line. This really made me angry. You can't create a new system then not follow the rules. this just encourages the line jumpers and causes the folks that were obeying the rules to now cheat as well. they know you are not enforcing the rules so they cut in front of those of us following the rules. You need to remember that we are the reason you changed the rules. those of us that fly round-trip flights every week on business. I applaud the several gate attendants that have been policing the boarding process. they explain the process well and check the boarding passes. For the incompetent PBI GA to say "gee, where did all the A1 thru 15 passengers go" is misleading, studid, not funny and just encourages line jumping. You are heading for trouble if you don't educate your GA's and your passengers!!! Saying "OK A1 thru 30" is causing problems. they simply need to say A 1-15, then A1 - 20, A 1 - 25, A1-30 in rapid succesion & everyone will then get the idea. Thursday's boarding was a disaster that will now just encourage rude passengers to continue that behavior. not happy at all..........

The execution of this new process is ridiculous! I'm supposed to be in the "A" list and yet, my boarding passes have ranged from A20 to B46. I flew the Tuesday before Thanksgiving and checked in 2 hours after the 24-hour window opened up and received B24. I called customer service and was assured that it was the best possible boarding pass given my status. The following day, I waited in line for the flight and watched as 30 college students boarded the flight ahead of me. So much for this "A" list. I've been on the phone with 5 customer service agents and no one seems to have an explanation. The fact is, the later I check in, the later my boarding pass. With over 100 credits in 2007, there is no way I should be getting B46 for any flight. The computer system assigning boarding passes is not working and this supposed "A" list is a sham.

I've been a loyal Southwest customer for years. With the exception of 2005, in which I took a break from traveling, I've earned a companion pass every year since 1999. As with others, unless Southwess fixes this problem, I will probably let me current reservations run out and switch carriers. Too bad, the friendly pilots and flight attendants should not have to pay for some ill-conceived business decision by the corporate office.

I've been a pleasure and business traveler on Southwest for years. I could never figure out why east-coasters had such distain for Southwest since they are typically always on time, have great customer service and the open seating policy is just fantastic.

Not so much anymore. This morning I became the latest victim of the new boarding policy. I checked in 23 hours and 57 minutes before my flight to end up in the B group position 08. What?!

I called and an agent explained that not only do Business Select customers get priority, but so do RR customers with at least 32 segments in the last year. So that's how I ended up in the B group. Even though I paid the business (not select) fares.

So I paid more but still end up sitting in B? United Airlines offers guaranteed seating on a more convenient schedule and to an airport closer to my destination for not much more money -- Maybe $80 more. And since I fly this route about 10 times a year, I think I'll definitely be switching to United since they seem to value my patronage a little more than Southwest's new "Pay more or travel more frequently and we'll like you BETTER" policy.

This is a complete slap in the face to business travelers who might not travel as frequently as Southwest would like or to those of us that enjoyed getting to the airport early so that we could sit in what I now call "Southwest's 15 rows of 'first class'".

And I'll *definitely* stop recommending Southwest to my friends, family and my 6,000 co-workers -- about 15%-20% who travel all over North America.

Why pay more (or even slightly less than the competitors) and get less?

You guys stuck out. BIG TIME.

Hey Jeff, see my comments above yours. If it's any consolation, I have 110 credits inn 2007, earned a companion pass and am supposed to be in the "A" list. Yet, I've been assigned from as low as A21 to a high of B46. 3 weeks ago, I checked my wife in without a rapid reward number and she got a boarding pass ahead of me. She hasn't flown Southwest in over 2 years!!!

I finally reached a Southwest customer service agent who was honest that the new process is not working for my account and he'd have to forward it on for further research. In the mean time, I'll have to stand by at the computer to check-in right when the 24 hour window opens...along with the other 100+ traverlers on the flight.

I'm looking forward to using up my last reservation in a few weeks. I've spoken with United and they have agreed to upgrade me to their higher tier status given the 10 reservations I just booked with them.

Sorrry SWA...

Well, I've already posted above my objection to the new fare structure. Since then, I've flown 2 rt's SNA-PHX (booked and paid for prior to the failed changes) and for both flights, boarding numbers were not enforced. It seemed that the very front of the A line was filled with squatters who saw the gap and took it. On another note, I think that I MAY like the new Business Select class. Silly to offer a drink to someone who may well be headed toward a meeting. But it can be rewarding to sit next to one of them and be offered their drink coupon since they won't be drinking anyway. Now if I can just learn how to spot them! Well, no worries....I won't be flying SWA after my current itineraries are complete...I don't like the feeling of standing in line after recess to get back into the classroom......

Dear Mr. Kelly,

Southwest has been our airline of first choice for nearly 15 years. We have earned a companion pass for three years in a row. My wife, young daughter and I fly together on your airline on average at least twice a month, and by all reasonable measures are loyal and valued customers of Southwest Airlines. WeÃ

Just had my first experience with the new boarding system and I really think you've got it right. (You can't believe how much I despised the old cattle call) I also have no hang up with saving some preferred seating slots for full fare customers.
Considering how far this airline has come over the years, it makes me wonder why I remained so loyal to one of the legacy carriers for over 800K miles. They should be so progressive.
Thanks and keep up the good work

Having read most of the comments regarding the new procedures and fares I am surprised at all the whining.

If SWA's last minute business fares for a particular market are higher than their competitions', then they will be forced to lower their fares in order to keep their business customers. The example of the $800 verses $340 fare could simply mean that the SWA flight in question may have been within two or three seats of being full. Airlines typically adjust their fares upwards as full capacity is approached and drastically lower them when it becomes apparent that a flight will have many vacant seats.

If the business traveler is paying closer to a competitive fare, it benefits the non-business traveler who relies on internet specials and "Ding" fares by allowing the airline to offer more lower fares in these categories. I am willing to be in the dreaded "B" group in order to have the lower end fares.

It is true that if SWA doesn't enforce the boarding order at their airports, ill feelings will worsen. Gate attendants need to be proactive in enforcing this. However, I am very grateful not to have to stand (if I sit, will I be able to get up?) in line at my age.

Finally, only time will test these new procedures and, given SWA's history, if some of them are broke, they will fix them.

I just checked in online as soon as the web site would allow me. A25. 25th in line. I'm meant to sit down and relax while I wait to board. Relax, knowing that there are 24 people in front of me competing for the 10 seats that my 6'11" frame will fit in without my knees pressing into the back of the seat in front of me. The fact that I used to be able to show up early and get at the head of the line was the main reason to fly Southwest. I sincerely hope you'll reconsider these decisions.

Fix the Companion Pass. When a Southwest customer qualifies for a Companion Pass, make sure his/her Companion gets a number that is sequencially right behind the Southwest FF who qulified for the Pass. That way they can board together, have their carry-on bags together and enjoy the trip together that the loyal customer qualfied for.

Southwest Guys,

I've been a customer since 1998. I attempted to book our annual March flight to Salt Lake last week and discovered the "benefits" of the new Rapid Reward program. You've done a terrific job here, selling out your loyal customers in order to pander to business customers at higher fares.

I discovered that except for 2 and a half rows of seats on your planes, my rapid rewards award was useless but I could turn it into a "freedom reward" for twice the number of rapid reward trips ! Basically THIS CUTS MY RAPID REWARD BENEFIT IN HALF AND CUTS IN HALF THE VALUE OF MY SOUTHWEST VISA CARD BENEFITS !! While you were at it, you should have cut the value of your drink coupons in half as well, from 3 to six required for a drink.

What's the value of that on your books - basically eliminating half the liability of your rapid reward award travel ? I'd like to see that accounting entry !

So here's what I'm going to do in response to your program changes.

1. I'm cutting my loyalty to SW to zero, treating you like any other airline, where I have plenty of miles, can get assigned seating in premium economy, and upgrade possibilities. I will go to great lengths not to fly Southwest.
2. Directing my admin assistant NOT to book my business travel on Southwest - might as well give my business to the other airlines
3. Informing Chase that I'm dropping my SW Visa, and use my bank-issued credit card instead.

Happy Holidays yourself !

One PO'd customer !

I have been a loyal customer of SWA since 1991 and have flown SWA almost exclusively for business and pleasure. I earned companion passes for over 4 straight years until I retired in 2006. I have taken part in your focus groups and I am very disappointed that you took a simple system that did not favor anyone to one that favors only a select few. After years of being a loyal customer we found on a recent flight that it is now almost impossible to get an 'A' boarding pass. Your new boarding procedures make SWA just like every other airline which takes away the main reason for flying SWA.

Like others I will be cutting up my SWA Visa card and switching to other airlines but since I am not flying much any more your marketing people must have felt that I would not be missed!!! To bad the "LUV" is gone.

Recently I was inadvertently booked on SW Airlines and was surprised that SW has upgraded from Cattle Class to more ordered seating system. However I was able to convince my Company to book me through any other airline but SW, until they can get their act together and start assigning seats. I will be looking to read about it in the news.

This is what happens when you promote an account to CEO: Gary Kelly has decided to discontinue having those little pepper packets which will save the airline $8,000 per year. What a moron. That same flight had a dozen or so passengers with lost luggage, and dozens of bags destined for Denver sitting on the carousel, so SWA must have spent about $8,000 delivering peoples' bags to them for that flight. The customers are angry, the flight crews, gate agents, and counter staff are furious and very negative about it, and investors are fleeing. After 20 years of flying SWA, investing in SWA, and believing in the SWA business model, I've now shifted most of my business trips to other airlines and taking a short position in LUV shares. Fire Gary Kelly and I'll reconsider.

I fly 4 - 8 rt/month depending on personal & business schedule. I TOTALLY applaud the boarding and other changes made to make the SW experience better for business travlers like me. I do agree with the many comments made here that the gate agents have to be diligent in handling the boarding process. I have seen several folks recently who apparently can't read numbers and were attempting to board well before their numbers were reached.
I also agree with earlier comments about off-duty SW employees who receive priority boarding as well as some passengers I've seen who are in better health than me who receive handicapped preboard. I know that the gate agents aren't doctors and can't do anything about this.
For the whiners about the new process who travel infrequently I'd like to ask them to look at all the other major airlines that all cater to business travelers with ticketing, upgrade and boarding policies. I had a problem before with folks who aparently had plenty of time to get to the a/p two hours+ early for a short flight and then stand in the A line for an hour so they could get preference with their discount tickets when I paid full unrestricted fares and often boarded B or C because my schedule prevented me from hanging out at the a/p. To these folks I say: PONY UP the cost of a full fare ticket ticket and you'll get preferential treatment just like on the other major airlines. If you travel infrequently and want a cheap fare PLEASE be prepared to board with others that paid about what you did. If SW only had this group they wouldn't be in business very long at current fuel and service costs.
I haven't chatted with a fequent business traveler yet who didn't support the changes. We know we are the lifeblood of the U.S. airline industry and we appreciate the recognition. Please continue to enhance the frequent traveler experience and we'll continue to support the airline.

Don't give up on the new boarding system. it is starting to work. As you know I fly SWA round trip every week on business. my flights this week were handled pretty well by the gate attendants. as many have been discussing, the gate attendants need to provide clear, proper direction to the passengers (explain it every flight as alot of passengers haven't flown under the new system so they still think they need to rush the gate) and I think we all will have a civilized boarding process. the best boardings I have had involved the GA saying we will board in numerical order, A1, 2, 3, 4, etc. or A1 is up front and A30 is back there. Saying OK A1 through 30 can board now creates a disaster. As I have said before, the missing A1 through 15 passengers creates many line jumping situations. not sure what you can do about that. The secret lies in the Gate Attendant providing succinct directions announcing that "hey folks, we have a new boarding process so listen up here a second" and not allowing gate jumpers to rush the gate. Please don't be supportive of the rude line jumping behavior or you will be losing customers. The new system can work well with proper instruction from the Attendants. Please hang with it and please do not go back to the old system where I had to fight for my turf in line for 2 hours before the flight; unable to go to the bathroom or get a bite to eat for fear of getting booted out of the line.

I like the assignment of numbers so that I don't have to stand in line for a long time. Especially given that I mostly fly SW for business and can't get to the airport hours ahead of time.

I am less excited, however, about the business select bit. There are a billion other airlines where sales folks with nice fat travel budgets can buy their way onto a plane early. I travel for the gov't and must take the cheapest tickets I can find always. It was nice to fly on SW, knowing that it was the one airline I was treated no better or worse than anyone else.

So, for the fatcat travelers -- if you don't like standing in line with the great unwashed, go fly on those other airlines -- they are for you anyway.

Please, Southwest, remove the classification of passengers. Keep the numbers, but kill the special perks for those who have money to spend on their place in line. Let them check-in early on the web like the rest of us.

- A not-so-thrilled SW business traveler

I have been a long-term customer of SWA and have acclimated to the concept of "open seating" and first come first serve (whether it was the old plastic numbered boarding cards or the newer on-line boarding passes). The idea of numbering the boarding passes within the A, B & C boarding groups for queuing has been a marked improvement but this new concept of paying a premium for preferential boarding passes may end up relegating SWA to the demise of the other airlines that don't know how to make a profit and are pathetic on services.

I, for one, will not pay a premium to SWA for the "privilege" of an earlier boarding pass and will start searching other airlines for same city-pair flights as SWA has lost one of the benefits previously afforded to keep all customers equal (i.e. equal opportunity for an early boarding pass).

Whoever developed this harebrained scheme likely worked for Coca Cola when they decided to dump Coke for the "new and improved Coke" which turned out to be a dismal failure and the recognition that "Classic Coke" was actually smarter all along.

SWA, please reconsider this insidious plan.

Ed

Is CORPORATE LISTENING? WE NEED A CHANGE!

i am a long time shareholder, frequent flyerand supporter of southwest airlines. while i have not flown since the new changes in boarding policies went into effect, i applaud them. it always made me mad having to get to the airport more than an hour ahead of the flight time just so i could obtain an "a" position. and then i had to stand in line. what a bad deal especially for someone with a bad back.
while your on-time service was very good, your boarding procedure always made me feel i was in a cattle call line. i am glad managment looked to increasing service rather than just increasing business.
i have always felt you folks were the best run airline in the business. now if you can only get your biz model successfully modified so your stock price will back where it should be.

Just to follow-up:

My experience with the new boarding policy was just as I had expected -- AWFUL. I ended up in the dreaded middle seats both ways. It would be one thing if I flew another carrier and when I bought my tickets I KNEW those were the only seats available, but in most cases you still get some kind of choice if you plan your flights early enough.

Whether I pick a SWA flight two months, two weeks or two days in advance, I'm still going to end up in the "B" or lower "A" boarding groups. Which means I'm still going to get stuck with those awful middle seats. (I had a business-class ticket even! But not one of the top-of-the-line business tickets, I guess. First class on SWA? Who knew?!)

PLUS since at BUR the passengers board and deplane from the front and the rear, the new boarding process caused a lot of "traffic" while boarding. People walking from the back to the front and the front to the back in search of dwindling bin space.

It was awful. Terrible. Took forever to get off the plane and people were grouchy when you tried to exit and they needed to "go against the flow" to get their bags.

I fly the BUR>SJC route often and use SWA because of their low rates. But considering that United has pretty competitive BUR & LAX>SFO rates (which is closer to my office), I'm going to request that our agent always book me on United as a rule and on SWA as a backup. At least I know if I plan in advance that the agent can guarantee me an aisle seat!

It's an unfortunate situation because I used to really like SWA and I would insist that people who had never flown them before at least give it a try. Now I do the opposite and have warned business colleagues and friends about the new boarding policy.

MY wife and I have flown southwest from Indinapolis Ind.to Las Vegas twice a year for quite a few years. We have always been well satisified with Southwest. The "cattle call" type boarding was getting to be a hassle when you get into your late 60'S. Our experience this Dec with the new boarding procedure at Indy was GREAT. I watched a earlier flight board at our gate and the gate agent announced numerous times how the boarding was to be done. Two men decided that they would board with the A's when one of them had a high B and the othe had a C. The agent told both of them to wait their turn, she have to tell one of them twice because he kept trying to jump ahead in the line. After the plane was boarded I went ot her supervisor and told them what a great job that the gate agent did, and was told to pass it on to the agent. She said thanks this is what the policy is and I and trying to do it right but it can get a big hassle if you let the people push you around.
Flew out of Las Vegas Dec 16 our boarding passes were A26 and A27 There were people with B and C boarding passes in the A1 to A25 lines, I questioned the boarding agent about this and his reply was so what do you want me to do about it , I replied just enforce the boarding policy, his response it not worth the hassle.
Like the new boarding GREAT GREAT
If others don't like it let them fly with anothe airline and the one's of us that do we will be able to get all the A boarding numbers.
Just try to get all boarding agents like the one in Indinapolis who had the GUT'S to tell people trying to jump ahead go back and wait your turn like everyone else , then if they do, then their supervisers have to have the GUTS to back them up.
GREAT job SOUTHWEST love the new boarding

Hello, I have been a Southwest Customer for the past 12 years and I really enjoy flying your airline. The New Boarding Process is wonderful. I travel alot with my 2 nieces who are 6 and 3 and lately have had some trouble getting seats together with them. I understand that if we have access to a computer we can sign on 24 hrs in advance and get boarding passes but whenever i do i'm always in "B" boarding group. Whenever we have boarded with the "Family Boarding" and cannot find seats together we ask the Flight Attendants if they can find us seats together and everytime we have asked, nobody has moved to accomodate us. I find this very disturbing since I am traveling with two very young girls. Because YOU are SOUTHWEST i know you will take all of the comments your Valued Customers give you to heart and come to some kind of resolution. Thank you for being such a great airline!

Luv,
Leeann

I travel quite often on southwest airlines and i favor the old boarding process for Families with small children. I do not have children and with the old way i could choose not to sit by these families, because they would board first go all the way to the back and take their seats and not have to worry about a "stranger" sitting next to their children. With the new family boarding i have been stuck next to a mother with a screaming 2 year old, and i also have been sitting by a mother with an infant and her 4 year old because it was the ONLY seat left on the aircraft. Please take these comments in consideration the next time you change your boarding procedures and try and make it better for everybody. I LOVE the old Southwest Family PRE-BOARDING!!

Thanks,
Mildred

Gary,

I fly Southwest almost every week to commute to my office in Tennessee. I really appreciate the option of "buying" my way into a business select fare with the appropriate additional benefits. If I want to choose the other fare classes, that remains an option.

I luv the new boarding procedures. By not having to stand in line for an hour or longer prior to boarding allows for less stress at the gate and a more pleasant flying experience.

I have no objection to allowing families with kids to board first (regardless of their ages) as I travel with my family and this is a real stress buster.

Thanks for letting me share my thoughts.

A 5:35 PM EST return flight tomorrow. Tried to check in as earlier as possible. Even got an error message timestamped at 5:35:02. Ended up with A43. This system is a huge mistake. Please comes to your senses.

Do NOT keep the numbers. They are failing MISERABLY. When I check in at 2 seconds after 24 hours ahead, and get an ERROR telling me I'm too early, only to get A43 5 seconds later, I know that you're system is BROKEN, BROKEN, BROKEN!

GO BACK TO THE WAY IT WAS.

Have flown 6 flights using new boarding system, it works great. But, I must say the new ticket prices are a disaster. Prices fluctuate all over the scale for no apparent reason, changing from day to day. I can fly BWI to the west coast cheaper than BWI to West Palm Beach (one third the distance). Ding fares from BWI are a joke. Is anybody really going to pay 3 times the price for the BS fare, just to board first and get a "free" drink? ( I have about 40 free drink coupons if anyone wants them) Please, bring back common sense pricing. Dave

The new boarding system is working great for me!

Ã

I've flown a couple of round-trips since the new boarding procedure was implemented and neither experience was a good one. In one case, the Southwest airport employee boarded people without referring to the numbers and it angered many fliers, who had taken the time to print out boarding passes 24 hours ahead of time as well as move up and down the line trying to find out where to stand.

In addition, it's just become too much of a hassle. I can easily book on other airlines which cost about the same and have the seat I want already selected before I even get to the airport.

I travel somewhat often and the new system isn't practical. It's created more "airport anxiety" for those who fly less often so once I receive my next RR flight award, Southwest will no longer be my airline of choice. I'm sorry to say this because I live in one of the hubs and have always enjoyed flying Southwest. For those of us who fly more often, it's just easier to book a flight with a confirmed seat.

Regards,
Marcia M. Neel

Marcia summed it up well. Boarding just creates too much "airport anxieity."

I have always flown southwest, until recently when fares are skyrocketing. i do not have a problem with the new boarding system and never had a problem with the old one. its not really about the boarding procedure that SW has anything to do with...its their customers. if people would only learn to show others respect, people wouldnt be taking out their anger on SWA. People....its not a race to the gate..i have found that if you wait your turn, and be patient that you usually will end up with what you want..and if you dont get what you want, then suck it up. have a drink or two on the plane...everything will be okay.

Gary,

Are you still reading this blog? Your screwy new fare structures have greatly increased our cost to fly with SW (about 25%) and you've cut the value of your rewards in HALF! Your new boarding policy has slowed the boarding process by forcing families to find seats halfway through the boarding process. Assigned seating would prevent a search for available seats through rows and rows of single seaters. Now flight attendants are rushing families down the aisle as they carry seats for their children and looking for seats. Your BS "Freedom" rewards are far more available than the standard awards, even well down your schedule. This "gotchya," predatory mentality is turning off your most loyal customers. And all of this foolishness to appeal to business customers who scoff at Southwest? Chase the almighty short-term dollar and youÃ

I was just about to buy my first SW tickets ever, to Orlando
from Philadelphia, and have read the comments about
the new boarding processes. Looks like upper management did not
realize that the people on the firing line (almost judging from some
comments) were stuck with enforcing a poorly drawn up system
and appears that many if not most are not enforcing the new
rules.
I go to Fla for a vacation, and would hate to start with a
hassle, either from a gatekeeper or nasty fellow passengers. I am
not going to fly SW to Orlando- or anywhere. l hope this matter is resolved
as I would like to fly SW that I have heard so much about on
a positive basis before this matter came up.

8 flights now using the new boarding method, itÃ

My husband and I flew to Las Vegas in early December and discovered a problem with the new boarding process. I got my boarding number at home, but my husband was denied and had to go to the agent at the airport. The agent said it was because he has a common name and had to be checked against the "watch" list. She cleared him and gave him a high number in the C line. So, I had to go on early and save him a seat.

Can't the system still issue the boarding number, but mark the pass "check in required"? That would give these passengers the same chance for early boarding.

It is amazing how many loyal SWA customers do not like the new system and have already moved their business to other carriers. I work for a large company and most of our employees are now requesting other airlines. SWA always had a comfortable, smaller airline feel that is quickly being lost. Why hassle with the new system when you can reserve a seat on another airline. We miss the old SWA and hope that the new CEO is listening before it is too late.

I also am very unhappy with the new Rapid Reward free ticket system. I can not use my free tickets on the flights I desire, they are always "Unavailable". They have cancelled the flights I would normally use from ISP to the West Coast or changed them so that it will take 11 or 12 hours to get there.
My vacation time is very precious and the less time in the travel part the better. I will also be cancelling my Southwest Visa card and switch to a carrier that has a better schedule. I really will miss the old Southwest.

I miss the old Southwest as well. The boarding system never mattered as much to me as the low fares (although the boarding system is worse now). I would always go to SWA first when looking for flights and, after seeing the fares, would not even be tempted to look at other airlines. I travel frequently to visit my parents and the low prices WERE refreshing. It's really unfortunate that you would stoop to the level of other airlines at the expense of your customers for profit. Actions speak louder than words.

hi my name is chase winks I love your airline iam a future pilot for your airline. In my room i have every thing of southwest airlines in my room.I have flown your airline 6 times. The flight Attendance & pilot are the best so you shoud give them a thumbs up. And your fares are awsome. And i am so CRAZY adout your airline.

thank you Chase Winks

It's bad enough to know that the current management of SWA has tosssed all consideration for their passengers to the wind with their boarding procedures and fare structures, but IT IS INCOMPREHENSIBLE THAT THE AIRLINE I TRUST ABOVE ALL OTHERS HAS THUMBED THEIR NOSE AT REQUIRED INSPECTIONS. I have TRUSTED YOU WITH MY LIFE for years as I fly. Do you care about your passengers at all anymore? What about your faithful employees who serve as crew? Are they "throw away" status too? I feel outraged, disappointed and betrayed. Herb and Colleen, they may have learned the business under your guidance and standards, but once you left, greed has replaced all the high standards you developed. So sad.

Jan - The inspections in question were one of many routine, redundant, and overlapping inspections of our fleet. As an article from todayÃ

For years when people would ask me which airlines I was flying, I would respond with "Southwest. Is there another airlines?" Well, sadly I am being forced to consider that there are other airlines and that their rates are now often times better! I look at the rates on the website and I am shocked by the amounts I am seeing. I have been putting off making a flight reservation for an impending trip because I am just so loyal that I am convinced there will be a special or something that renews my faith in Southwest, but time is running out. Other airlines are looming in my future! Sigh.....

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Flash node macros can be added to this post.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <HTML> <object> <embed><a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <i> <b> <script>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Insert Flickr images: [flickr-photo:id=230452326,size=s] or [flickr-photoset:id=72157594262419167,size=m].
  • Inline assets are allowed.

Southwest Airlines Blog

Nuts about Southwest is all about our Employees, Customers, airplanes, and airports. We really are Nuts about Southwest and we hope that our Readers will share that passion by posting their own comments.

For more information about the blog and participating, please visit our User Guide.

Syndicate This Blog

Exclusive Southwest Offers Right on Your Desktop

Download Our
Mommy Blogger Patches

Southwest Airlines

Tags



     View all tags

Archives

 2009
   •  November 2009
   •  October 2009
   •  September 2009
   •  August 2009
   •  July 2009
   •  June 2009
   •  May 2009
   •  April 2009
   •  March 2009
   •  February 2009
   •  January 2009
 2008
 2007

Categories

Link Luv

CREATED
BY RD2